Baseball Card Hall of Fame Golden Age of Baseball Poll 1/28/17

[T206]

This will be the first poll for Golden Age of Baseball cards that will be voted on to get inducted into the BCHOF. For more information and prior Hall of Fame inductees, read this main thread: http://www.blowoutcards.com/forums/baseball/1080616-official-blowout-baseball-card-hall-fame.html#post11875198


Below are a list of ten cards from 1946-1969. Vote on the ones which you think deserves to be in the Blowout Baseball Card Hall of Fame. Any card that breaks 50% will make the Hall of Fame this time around. If it does not break 50% the card going on the next ballot. If a card does not get any votes, it is banned from getting inducted into the BCHOF.

Card #1: 1948 Leaf Jackie Robinson
359691
Card #2: 1951 Bowman Mickey Mantle
359693
Card #3: 1952 Topps Mickey Mantle
359695
Card #4: 1952 Bowman Willie Mays
359694
Card #5: 1954 Topps Ernie Banks
359696
Card #6: 1954 Topps Hank Aaron
359697
Card #7: 1955 Topps Roberto Clemente
359698
Card #8: 1959 Topps Bob Gibson
359699
Card #9: 1967 Topps Tom Seaver Rookie
359700
Card #10: 1968 Topps Nolan Ryan Rookie Card
359701

Post which cards you voted on and let me know which cards you want to see in the next BCHOF poll, which will cover MODERN BASEBALL CARDS!


Four cards made it this time around :)!
Thanks for voting!


*Poll closed at Saturday at 8:30 EST

[carlo16]

Bowman Color Pee We Reese
52 Pafko
56 Mantle
63 Rose
69 Bench
55 Koufax

[rats60]

Why do you have the 52 Bowman Mays instead of the 51 Bowman? Where is the 55 Topps Koufax. I vote for those two.

[6celtics33]

Yes I voted for the Mays just assuming it was the 51. That makes no sense. Edit it or don't count my vote for accuracy.

[T206]

Thanks for all the future choices guys!
I am going on memory the first time around so obviously there will be a few that I miss. Next time, we have a lot to choose from :)!

[jstephens24]

only voting on 3 right? voted 52 Mantle, 54 Aaron and 68 Ryan

[T206]

Bowman Color Pee We Reese
52 Pafko
56 Mantle
63 Rose
69 Bench
55 Koufax

Why do you have the 52 Bowman Mays instead of the 51 Bowman? Where is the 55 Topps Koufax. I vote for those two.

Yes I voted for the Mays just assuming it was the 51. That makes no sense. Edit it or don't count my vote for accuracy.

only voting on 3 right? voted 52 Mantle, 54 Aaron and 68 Ryan
Vote for as many as you want :)!

[T206]

Looking like there might be four Hall of Fame Cards this time around!

[T206]

Only an hour left! make sure you vote and be a good American

[preakness]

Mantle 52 should be 100%

[preakness]

Mantle 52 should be 100%

[6celtics33]

51 Mantle at 38%. Tough crowd.

[Hollywood42]

I had to vote for all of them. They're iconic

[T206]

Four cards made it this time around! Thank you to all those who voted

[Prenticles]

Not the Mantle RC or Clemente RC? I know the public voted but come on.

Not mentioning Jerry Koosman on the Nolan Ryan RC? Disappointing. ;)

People forget Jerry Koosman was a good (nearly HOF worthy) pitcher. The card was not like a 1998 NFL Draft one (Peyton Manning who has an argument for Top 10 All Time QB, and Ryan Leaf who has an argument for biggest QB draft bust with Jamarcus Russell.)

[T206]

Not the Mantle RC or Clemente RC? I know the public voted but come on.

Not mentioning Jerry Koosman on the Nolan Ryan RC? Disappointing. ;)

People forget Jerry Koosman was a good (nearly HOF worthy) pitcher. The card was not like a 1998 NFL Draft one (Peyton Manning who has an argument for Top 10 All Time QB, and Ryan Leaf who has an argument for biggest QB draft bust with Jamarcus Russell.)

Hard crowd lol
No one loves Koosman more than me.