Panini redemption replacements

[nyisle]

So, its been almost 3 years since I stopped collecting, and was just looking at my Panini account. Have 10 redemptions that are all over 3 years old from Football, Hockey and Basketball.

I am waiting on a Klay Thompson 2012-13 Intrigue RC Auto Memorabilia card #156 Limited to /15.

Anyone have an idea of value on this? And how screwed over am I about to get?

[MintSkoaly]

I think Panini is more than fair with redemption replacements . It's Topps you have to worry about.

[rice71]

You can see if they can take all your redemption or some and replace it for one big card. Give them names of players you collect. Last year I traded two baseball redemptions and got a Steph curry auto.

[nyisle]

You can see if they can take all your redemption or some and replace it for one big card. Give them names of players you collect. Last year I traded two baseball redemptions and got a Steph curry auto.

Unfortunately I have been kind of out of the hobby for a few years now and really do not follow anyone. Prefer hockey over the other sports but Panini no longer makes hockey.

[cardsharkk]

Unfortunately I have been kind of out of the hobby for a few years now and really do not follow anyone. Prefer hockey over the other sports but Panini no longer makes hockey.

ike someone else said try to get them to lump them together for one better card. If they do this you prob wanna ask for a player who sells well, like Giannis, or Curry. Sell and buy what you like.

[stangy24]

From my experience, Panini is pretty good about giving quality redemption replacements.

[nyisle]

Got an update.
After emailing my contact at the 11 business week mark, i finally got "A" replacement. And yes I stressed tbe "a." So i asked for 10 cards to be replaced and so far the best i can tell is i am getting 1 card in return. Everything was combined into 1 order # and that order was just updated to show the shipping link. And there is only 1 new card added with the shipping link.

Has anyone else had this happened?

[kingofsnake]

Yes, when swapping out old redemptions I was asked whether I want one for one or combined. Good luck with yours. I've found that Panini has been generally fair.

[nyisle]

They asked me for a list of 5 players... i guess i cant complain since the replacement was on that list

[mfisher27]

They asked me for a list of 5 players... i guess i cant complain since the replacement was on that list

What was it?

[nyisle]

It says Peyton Manning 2014 Crown Royale Silhouettes Autograph Purple. And in the numbering column says 4/5

[kingofsnake]

The Peyton sounds nice. Don't know what the other 9 cards you gave up were, but the Klay was a sticker auto I believe.

[buckunteer]

wow...yeah you ok :)!

[nyisle]

The Peyton sounds nice. Don't know what the other 9 cards you gave up were, but the Klay was a sticker auto I believe.

I'll let you guys be the judge
1. LaMichael James 2012 Contenders RC Silhouette /349
2. Derrick Coleman 2012 Intrigue Red White & Blue Auto /199
3. Derek Wolfe 2012 Gridiron RC Sig "Os" /25
4. Jordan Reed 2013 Momentum RC Sig Silver /99
5. Martin Brodeur 2012 Limited Monikers Silver /25
6. Kevin Jones 2012 Innovation RC Innovative Ink
7. OJ Mayo 2012 Absolute Iconic Auto /99
8. Klay Thompson 2012 Intrigue RC Auto Memorabilia /15
9. Alec Olgatree 2013 Momentum RC Initiation Sig /299
10. Dion Waiters 2012 Crusade Quest Auto

Only one I am truly bummed about is the Brodeur.

[jbettis32]

I'll let you guys be the judge
1. LaMichael James 2012 Contenders RC Silhouette /349
2. Derrick Coleman 2012 Intrigue Red White & Blue Auto /199
3. Derek Wolfe 2012 Gridiron RC Sig "Os" /25
4. Jordan Reed 2013 Momentum RC Sig Silver /99
5. Martin Brodeur 2012 Limited Monikers Silver /25
6. Kevin Jones 2012 Innovation RC Innovative Ink
7. OJ Mayo 2012 Absolute Iconic Auto /99
8. Klay Thompson 2012 Intrigue RC Auto Memorabilia /15
9. Alec Olgatree 2013 Momentum RC Initiation Sig /299
10. Dion Waiters 2012 Crusade Quest Auto

Only one I am truly bummed about is the Brodeur.

You're doing good in this trade...:)! Brodeur may gets you $30? but the rest are just......

[kingofsnake]

I'll let you guys be the judge
1. LaMichael James 2012 Contenders RC Silhouette /349
2. Derrick Coleman 2012 Intrigue Red White & Blue Auto /199
3. Derek Wolfe 2012 Gridiron RC Sig "Os" /25
4. Jordan Reed 2013 Momentum RC Sig Silver /99
5. Martin Brodeur 2012 Limited Monikers Silver /25
6. Kevin Jones 2012 Innovation RC Innovative Ink
7. OJ Mayo 2012 Absolute Iconic Auto /99
8. Klay Thompson 2012 Intrigue RC Auto Memorabilia /15
9. Alec Olgatree 2013 Momentum RC Initiation Sig /299
10. Dion Waiters 2012 Crusade Quest Auto

Only one I am truly bummed about is the Brodeur.

I think you did well too. A lot of sticker auto fodder there. The Brodeur - while nice - seems to be on one of those manufactured patches.

[arashY]

The Klay seems nice

[kmunch811]

I personally think you killed it!

That Klay is a very nice card, but also is a sticker auto from a lower end set. A lot of collectors love the silhouette and the patch window is much larger than it would be on the Klay, with a chance for a nasty patch (probably game worn vs. event worn as well)

[nyisle]

As much as I wanted the Brodeur I have a nice quad relic Auto from the Cup.
I was concerned about the value of the Klay, but from what you guys are saying I am not losing much on it.

[kmunch811]

It looks Like the Manning 18/18 from that year sold for $300. Looking at some recently sold Klay RPA's from Immaculate, it still looks like you're coming out ahead.

http://www.watchcount.com/completed.php?bkw=peyton+manning+silhouette&bcat=64482&bcts=&sfsb=Show+Me%21&csbin=all&cssrt=ts&bslr=&bnp=&bxp=#serp (http://www.watchcount.com/completed.php?bkw=peyton+manning+silhouette&bcat=64482&bcts=&sfsb=Show+Me%21&csbin=all&cssrt=ts&bslr=&bnp=&bxp=#serp)

[nyisle]

So this just came.

https://sportscardalbum.com/c/shaw7b66x450.jpg?0 (https://sportscardalbum.com/card/shaw7b66/2013-panini-crown-royale-peyton-manning)