Should I try to re-crossover a card when I send in some true gems?

[CardsAnonymous]

I have a Zion Silver BGS 9.5 card (got a 9 centering even though it looks like it should have gotten 9.5 AT LEAST) that I tried to crossover to PSA with a minimum 10. I was floored when it came back still in a BGS slab.

Fast forward to today and I now have two true gem cards coming in that I am going to send in to crossover. My question to the panel is, should I try to send the Zion in again with them? Has anybody had success trying to cross a card over a 2nd time? Any and all help is appreciated.

[CardsAnonymous]

My apologies, please close. Reposted in grading forum

[rcearley]

I would recommend to crack the card from BGS and send in raw, that's your best shot at a PSA 10. I have never had any luck sending in a BGS case, but when I cracked and submitted raw I've had great success.

[BreaultCards]

I would recommend to crack the card from BGS and send in raw, that's your best shot at a PSA 10. I have never had any luck sending in a BGS case, but when I cracked and submitted raw I've had great success.

This crack it. They pop control
Hard but if you send it enough times you will get a 10 because it really is just a dog and pony show at the end of the day.

[thenwhatjk]

can’t hide C3PO boner!