'86 Fleer MJ Poll

[bryan2points]

Need your opinion, if you had a 1 choice what would you choose:
Fleer Jordan RC + sticker RC both PSA 9
or
Fleer Jordan RC BGS 9.5 (3x 9.5 1x9 subs)

[tjforce]

Trust your eye and get whichever base Jordan is in the best shape.

[GoHawks25]

Would have to see the card itself, not just the grade. Some BGS 9.5’s look better than others and some with PSA 9 look better than BGS 9.5’s.. If the PSA 9 looks no different than the BGS 9.5 obviously would go with the two 9’s. But to me the Fleer RC is the most iconic card in the whole basketball card market so the highest grade/best condition version of that card would take priority. So if the BGS 9.5 clearly looks nicer than the PSA 9 Fleer I’d go with that.

[GoHawks25]

Trust your eye and get whichever base Jordan is in the best shape.

I agree with this. I voted BGS 9.5, but only if the BGS 9.5 is noticeably in better condition.

[bryan2points]

There definitely isnt much difference in eye appeal between the PSA 9 and BGS 9.5. (3 9.5's and 9 subgrades)

Regardless of either choice...I should be grateful regardless right? Dunno why i'm stressing over this.

[hauntedcomputer]

Without the numbers on them, nobody could tell the difference between a 9 and 9.5.

So for keeping, I'd take the pair. For selling, I'd sell to someone who doesn't believe my previous statement.

[alwayson22]

I agree with this. I voted BGS 9.5, but only if the BGS 9.5 is noticeably in better condition.

+1, although I do think the 86 Fleer looks better in a PSA slab (just my personal preference)