Value compare: PSA 9 w/ 9 auto vs BGS 9 vs raw

[kiwicardtrader]

Hey folks,

Are these all similar values in high end? Is a PSA 9 with 9 auto worse or better than raw? Does it depend on the player?

What's your own buying and selling experience with this?



Sent from my SM-G975W using Tapatalk

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Personally, I would never buy a card with a graded auto less than 10. There are plenty of 10 Auto’s out there, no reason to take the hit. If you see the value dip BGS cards take when they have a 9 on the auto, it’s significant. It’s just not worth it.

[D-Lite]

A 9 auto is somehow the worst thing in the world. On modern cards it's death to a price. And you have some of these characters signing cards with a dead marker in a desert. Look at the disaster an Acuna auto is.

PSA 10 all the way.