PDA

View Full Version : Thicccc cards - Slabbed or ungraded?


Spacemanspif
12-30-2020, 02:37 PM
So I'm a big collector of RPAs and autos, and have a lot of cards that are of the "THICCCC" variety: NT, Immaculate, Opulence, Noir, etc. Personally, I like having them in simple one-touches, especially with the Panini sticker (makes it still feel "new"), and don't mind tiny nicks on the edges and corners because I understand that they are handled by the players who couldn't give a crap if your card is an 8 or a 9.5. My eyes are generally drawn towards the patch and autograph, and I think the tiny imperfections on the card give it personality, but maybe that's just me.

However, with current values where they are, I can also see how a buyer would want the cards graded so they know exactly what they are getting. With so many shady people out there, it's tough to trust someone with thousands of dollars on the line to disclose any and all flaws, I get that 100%. However, once a card is slabbed my eyes are immediately drawn to the grade, and then my judgment is already influenced by that before I start looking at the card itself.

With a lot of life changes coming for me, I'm looking at thinning out my collection this year, and I saw that PWCC no longer accepts ungraded cards, which means I'm probably going to have to get all of my high-end cards graded. Bye bye Panini seals!

Anyway, I included a poll to see how you would prefer to buy an expensive card, and would like to have a discussion on the preferences and reasonings behind them.

GeechQuest
12-30-2020, 02:48 PM
If you’re planning on selling these thiccccc boiz you should probably get them graded. Many people are miffed when their 130 point card has flaws and isn’t Gem Mint. At the very least you could get rid of that potential headache through grading.

JoeAdam
12-30-2020, 02:48 PM
I personally don't care if a thick card is graded or ungraded. I'm also transitioning to having PWCC do all my transactions, so unfortunately everything needs to be graded. They've become a no-brainer choice for everyone selling in the hobby.

mvp
12-30-2020, 05:25 PM
I specifically buy ungraded for my core PC, and am happy to do so for many of the reasons you suggested. But most of the cards are under $1,000.

If I was buying something to flip down the line, or something as an “investment” and spending over $1,000, I’d probably want graded. It’s just extra peace of mind in that everyone knows exactly what they’re getting - you as the buyer, and the guy you eventually sell it to.

Spacemanspif
01-01-2021, 05:23 PM
thanks for the replies guys. part of my 2021 resolution is to sell off a bunch of stuff and pay for "real-life" stuff, so now an addition to that is getting everything graded first. my USPS workers already know me but gonna be weird showing up to the post office every day with registered mail for like all of January lol