Bgs grades popped...half 9.5's

[officerp]

MY GRADES POPPED THE OTHER DAY AND I WILL HAVE THEM TOMORROW. OVERALL IM PRETTY PLEASED WITH 5 OF MY 10 GETTING 9.5'S. THOUGHT THE D ROSE SPA WOULD HAVE DID BETTER THAN AN 8.5 SO MY QUESTION IS, WHAT WOULD ITS VALUE BE? SAME AS RAW? LET ME KNOW HOW YOU THINK I CAME OUT?

2005 Topps Aaron Rodgers 9.5
2011 Bowman Prospects Bryce Harper 8.5
2011 Bowman Prospects Bryce Harper 9.5
2008-09 Fleer 1986-87 Rookies Derrick Rose 9.5
2008 Bowman Chrome Prospects Refractors Josh Vitters AU 9.0
2008-09 Bowman Chrome Derrick Rose 9.0
2008-09 SP Authentic Derrick Rose JSY AU/299 8.5
2006 Ultimate Collection Ultimate Scripts Jay Cutler 9.5
2006 SPx Rookie Autographs Gold Jay Cutler 9.0
2006 Playoff Contenders Jay Cutler AU/501 9.0

[mikecancelliere]

9 is the equivalent to raw so you should take the rose out

[rudyjustinfarrell]

The thick SPA/Sweet Spot type cards are super sensitive to dings/chips/flaws. You won't get top dollar for it, but I think you'd still get a RAW price. It's a D-Rose SPA after all?