Panini Redemption (Replacement) Mailday

[FavresReturn]

Just got this today from panini. I had a redemption of Dexter McCluster material phenoms gold (/10) from limited that I redeemed 12/1/10. I really wanted this card but felt like I was never going to see it. So I called this week and the guy gave me choices of the cards what they had in. I picked this:

http://i1193.photobucket.com/albums/aa342/Favresreturn/MJDFront.jpg

http://i1193.photobucket.com/albums/aa342/Favresreturn/MJDBack.jpg

[mindbinge]

yet another great warehouse find...wonder what else they have laying around that never escaped.

[jp98]

I hate them so much. You got a freaking replacement in a week! I have never been asked "choices" and they have told me a few times wait a little longer over and over.

[FavresReturn]

I called them a couple months ago and was like I need a replacement and I told them teams/players I liked so they said they would send one out. Nothing, so I called earlier this week and the guy gave me options so I made a choice and it arrived in 3 days. Got pretty lucky!

[rletlow]

It all depends on who you get on the phone.
I called about an expired Julio Jones rookie from 2007 and they replaced it with a Tony Dorsett Significant Sigs /15 from the same set.

I was also given a choice of players.
Time from 1st call to replacement arriving was 9 days.

[shockandawwe]

It all depends on who you get on the phone.
I called about an expired Julio Jones rookie from 2007 and they replaced it with a Tony Dorsett Significant Sigs /15 from the same set.

I was also given a choice of players.
Time from 1st call to replacement arriving was 9 days.

Julio Jones?? you mean calvin johnson from 07

[shockandawwe]

Is there a good time to call cause ive been waiting on a jerry jones redemption and its past the 8 month period they stated, and i emailed them and they said i only get one at random i dont want one at random

[FavresReturn]

Is there a good time to call cause ive been waiting on a jerry jones redemption and its past the 8 month period they stated, and i emailed them and they said i only get one at random i dont want one at random

lol.. well idk I called at approximately 4 pm on tuesday so maybe you'll get the same guy? ha

[jp98]

Who is the guy everybody is talking to? Please help.

[jusdukky]

Consider yourself lucky and one of the few that end up lucky. I had an 09 Certified auto of super stud Shawn Nelson. They sent me a message in Jan. that they never got him to sign for the Certified. I gladly told them to send me someone else and they got back and said they would replace it with someone else and it would ship in a couple of weeks. April rolls around and I contact them with no results. Finally in August they send me his EEE:eek::mad: Still waiting on about 10 other redemptions and will probably suffer thru the same sheet. They stink!!

[golfinglegend67]

I just called them and got a Dexter McCluster as a replacement for my Jonathon Dwyer certified FF auto that apparently isn't ever going to be made. I called them about 20 minutes ago and the phone barely even rang, I didn't catch the guys name but he was very helpful. I was pretty happy with the replacement.

[bubble]

I just called them and got a Dexter McCluster as a replacement for my Jonathon Dwyer certified FF auto that apparently isn't ever going to be made. I called them about 20 minutes ago and the phone barely even rang, I didn't catch the guys name but he was very helpful. I was pretty happy with the replacement.


Wow McCluster for Dwyer? I have that card redeemed as well. Hopefully I can get something that good

[jp98]

I just called them and got a Dexter McCluster as a replacement for my Jonathon Dwyer certified FF auto that apparently isn't ever going to be made. I called them about 20 minutes ago and the phone barely even rang, I didn't catch the guys name but he was very helpful. I was pretty happy with the replacement.

Sweet. Got a good deal there.

[justinj31]

thats odd I had a McCluster patch auto/15 they said wans't made. I got the guy today as well. he said he needed to get a bv from beckett, and what team i liked. we shall see.

[coltsnsox07]

I'm still waiting for a McCluster NFL shield auto 1/1 from Limited last year, I wonder if I could get something comparable for that card or keep waiting.

[rletlow]

Julio Jones?? you mean calvin johnson from 07

I meant it expired in 2007. It was a Julius Jones rookie card auto /10.

[FreeFlow]

I hate them so much. You got a freaking replacement in a week! I have never been asked "choices" and they have told me a few times wait a little longer over and over.

You have to wait exactly 4 months no matter what. I called the day my 20card redemption request hit 4 months in which I got 15 replaced.

Bad part is that was now 3 weeks ago and still no cards :(

[FreeFlow]

I'm still waiting for a McCluster NFL shield auto 1/1 from Limited last year, I wonder if I could get something comparable for that card or keep waiting.

If you PC him, Try this. Wait until his value goes up from starting. Call and ask if you can get the shield card with no auto since he is not signing, figure out the % difference of no auto/auto shields and get a couple extra cards.

Either way you will need to get a replacement, it won't be a shield but you should defiantly wait until his value goes up now, there's no doubt it will but who know how much.

[FavresReturn]

Panini told me the bv of my mccluster limited /10 was 60 which isn't too bad. At least my replacement was 40 over that

[jp98]

You have to wait exactly 4 months no matter what. I called the day my 20card redemption request hit 4 months in which I got 15 replaced.

Bad part is that was now 3 weeks ago and still no cards :(

I have waited 10 and I only chose 4 months lol..

[jp98]

I'm still waiting for a McCluster NFL shield auto 1/1 from Limited last year, I wonder if I could get something comparable for that card or keep waiting.

:)!:)!:)!:)!

If you ever get that...you know I will be wanting it:D

[barnsz]

You have to wait exactly 4 months no matter what. I called the day my 20card redemption request hit 4 months in which I got 15 replaced.

Bad part is that was now 3 weeks ago and still no cards :(


same thing for us told them who we wanted and all she said not a problem will ship out with-in a few days it has been almost 3 weeks called yesterday she told us that they will be going out first thing Monday Morning
so we will wait and see

[armyatc22]

Panini told me the bv of my mccluster limited /10 was 60 which isn't too bad. At least my replacement was 40 over that

Yeah i don't know where u got that info from but the MJD /5 isnt a $100 card lol

[FavresReturn]

Well then they definitely were lying to me but im not worried about value