Trade advice needed: 2-1

[RotoHester]

Side A)

Gets their choice of:

http://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa389/packerfan5052/002-1-2.jpg (#/25)

or

http://i1195.photobucket.com/albums/aa389/packerfan5052/005-6.jpg


for

Side B gives up:

2008 Leaf Certified Jordy Nelson Rookie Auto

and

2008 Bowman Sterling Jordy Nelson Auto Patch card #d/100


Two part question. How's the trade look and which card, if you had the choice, from side A would you pick in the trade?

[yankeesfan24]

im biased, but I would take the Dez auto

[imbaked247]

I'd go with the McFadden , not bad numbering seems fair and the Dez has a horrible sig
And Im a Charger fan lol!

[bradsholly]

well, If I remember right the jordy is a 1-color patch, i believe the #'d to 50 were the 2 colors.....if that is the case, I'd go with the mcfadden.

if its a 2 color on the sterling I'd say the guy getting the jordy's is getting one heck of a deal!!

[RotoHester]

The Nelson looks like it has a tiny stripe of white at the very top of the patch but it's mainly just green

[bradsholly]

i wouldn't even think about it then, I'd take the jordy's and run!!!

[ft28jags]

jordy would be my choice

[RotoHester]

Would that be considered a good trade when there are 3 options and someone would pick 1 of each, lol

[Clarka3]

i PC McFadden, so i'm biased.

[RotoHester]

You guys are awesome. Let me ask one more, since I can't find any recent sales on the Bowman Sterling auto /100 ... what price would you pay to purchase that one?

Thank you guys so much for the help. This is why I love this forum