Topps Redemption Issue

[tdmonkeys]

I received a 2008 Topps Co-Signers Tri-Signers with Hanley Ramirez, Jeremy Hermida, and Cameron Maybin as as redemption. After 2 months I was sent Clay Buchhoz, Phil Hughes, and Felix Hernandez as a replacement. I feel like I am being shorted but is this even worth pursuing. I feel as a repeat MVP candidate like Hanley should be matched on the replacement. Is this unreasonable?

[u_want_my_cards]

wow dude... call topps and tell them...

[Brad]

It can't hurt to call and see if they will do anything.

FWIW, I had a triple auto from Co-Signers that wasn't produced as well and was sent a box of 08 Triple Threads as a replacement.

[IndySportsCards]

Both boxes of 08 Co-Signers Baseball I purchased last year garnered me two dual autos of BOXERS.. Needless to say, I'll never buy that baseball product again. You did much better than me with both your redemption and replacement.

[hiimpaul123]

Hey I'll trade you my tri-signers auto for your replacement
http://i589.photobucket.com/albums/ss340/hiimpaul123/baseball/Tri-Sig001.jpg

[DadofTwins]

I would rather have what you received in exchange. - A Yankee, Red Sock, and King Felix definitley over Ramirez, (Overrated Hermida) and Maybin who had gotten sent down to the minors how many times already? Maybin may become a star.. but if he doesnt you have Hanley and what else on that card

[tdmonkeys]

I thought about that but after looking around, my impression is that he Ramirez auto alone far outweighs the replacement in value.