Rank your 5 WORST STARTING QB's in the NFL.

[Astronix]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

[ccrab1984]

You've got to be kidding me, Sanchez slightly worse than locker as proven last night

[sunsfan8]

Ryan Lindley
John Skelton
Blaine Gabbert
Brady Quinn
Mark Sanchez

[sunsfan8]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

Locker? Really? Locker's not that bad.

[patchgenie]

Ryan Lindley
John Skelton
Blaine Gabbert
Mark Sanchez
Matt Cassel

[ediii33]

Im gonna hold off ranking the first and second year QB's.

Cassell
Sanchez
Flacco
Bradford
Brady

[burke23]

I am amazed that Ponder just might miss the bottom 5 (top 5?)...I think that says more about the other qbs than it does about him, however.

[azviking101]

1. Mark Sanchez
2. Christian ponder
3. Blaine Gabbert
4. John Skelton
5. Michael Vick

[Clarka3]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

agree with this list completely.

[sooslow]

1. Mark Sanchez
2. Christian ponder
3. Blaine Gabbert
4. John Skelton
5. Michael Vick

Vick's no longer a starter.

[Astronix]

Locker? Really? Locker's not that bad.

Watching the game last night, Sanchez actually played better than Locker.

Gruden kept saying, and he was right, that Locker locked in on his primary receiver every play and did not do progressions at all. That is a DEATH sentence in the NFL.

The Titans did not trust him throwing the ball at all by the end of the game. If it weren't for his running ability he might be #2 on my list.

[GetBig14]

1. Lindley,Skelton (both stink)
2. Gabbert
3. Cassel, Quinn (both equally bad)
4. Sanchez
5. Bradford

[dherm360]

1. Lindley,Skelton (both stink)
2. Gabbert
3. Cassel, Quinn (both equally bad)
4. Sanchez
5. Bradford

good list but

1. Lindley,Skelton (both stink)
2. Gabbert
3. Cassel, Quinn (both equally bad)
4. Sanchez
5. Cutler

[GetBig14]

good list but

1. Lindley,Skelton (both stink)
2. Gabbert
3. Cassel, Quinn (both equally bad)
4. Sanchez
5. Cutler

I personally don't like Cutler because of his actions, but he isn't close to being on this list. hes no doubt a top 15 QB.

[ddearing]

Gabbert is not a starter. He will likely not be a starter in Jax again. Their really can't be anyone worse than Sanchez at least over the last three games. Incidentally, I think we will find that he is no longer a starter either.

[Earlsnake07]

1. Lindley,Skelton (both stink)
2. Gabbert
3. Cassel, Quinn (both equally bad)
4. Sanchez
5. Bradford

I would remove Bradford.......I dont think he is a bad QB...just bad situation. As far as both Chiefs QB's...I have them in the #2 spot.....

[Zacy87]

1. Skelton/Lindley
2. Quinn/Cassel
3. Sanchez
4. Palmer
5. Fitzpatrick

[Razorsharp79]

Mark Sanchez
Ponder
Gabbert or tannehill
Cassel
Weeden

[1eyed_jack]

I personally don't like Cutler because of his actions, but he isn't close to being on this list. hes no doubt a top 15 QB.

Cutler shouldn't be on the bottom 5 list, but there is no doubt in my mind that he is NOT a top 15 QB.

[allday_vikes]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

1. Christian Ponder
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Christian Ponder, sometimes I still have dreams that McNabb was still throwing to his WRs' feet! At least then, there's no chance of an INT.

[freethrowtommy]

After last night, how could Sanchez be left off ANY bottom 5 list? I would consider him bottom 3 material...

[creamybeige]

Im gonna hold off ranking the first and second year QB's.

Cassell
Sanchez
Flacco
Bradford
Brady

surely you mean brady QUINN right?

[creamybeige]

heres my list btw...

1. Sanchez
2. Ponder
3. Quinn
4. Stafford
5. Bradford

[sooslow]

I'm still waiting for one of the Cam haters on this forum to drop his name.

[Metsfan1121]

1. Chiefs
2. Cardinals
3. Sanchez
4. Ponder
5. Flacco

[mnvikingstwins]

Mark Sanchez
Brady Quinn/Chiefs
Blaine Gabbert
John Skelton/Lindley
Christian Ponder

[romo2austin2dez]

1.Cardinals QB (doesn't matter who they all stink)
2.mark sanchez
3.matt cassel/brady quinn
4.brandon weeden
5.ryan tannehill

[bdubs3316]

heres my list btw...

1. Sanchez
2. Ponder
3. Quinn
4. Stafford
5. Bradford

LMFAO.....:confused::confused::confused:

[Zacy87]

How is anyone putting Flacco or Stafford on a list before guys like Fitzpatrick and Palmer?

[creamybeige]

How is anyone putting Flacco or Stafford on a list before guys like Fitzpatrick and Palmer?

flacco: 20td 10int 3474yd 86.2qbr

Stafford:17td 15int 4252yd 78.9qbr

Fitz: 22td 15int 2935yd 83.5qbr

Palmer: 22td 14int 3987yd 85qbr


ONE OF THESE THINGS IS NOT LIKE THE OTHER (sorry bdubs)

flacco should be nowhere near this list though...

[bdubs3316]

How is anyone putting Flacco or Stafford on a list before guys like Fitzpatrick and Palmer?

or Foles.........

[bdubs3316]

flacco: 20td 10int 3474yd 86.2qbr

Stafford:17td 15int 4252yd 78.9qbr

Fitz: 22td 15int 2935yd 83.5qbr

Palmer: 22td 14int 3987yd 85qbr


ONE OF THESE THINGS IS NOT LIKE THE OTHER (sorry bdubs)

flacco should be nowhere near this list though...

yep...just forget the fact that the Lions have played one of the toughest schedules in the NFL. or that they've played statistically the toughest defenses this year...

no need to factor that in ;) :rolleyes: :)!

[Chaddie84]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

Pretty close. I think Sanchez cracks the top 5 IMO. I also would put Cardinals at the top simply because they have Larry Fitzgerald and still do squat.

[creamybeige]

yep...just forget the fact that the Lions have played one of the toughest schedules in the NFL.

no need to factor that in ;) :rolleyes: :)!

2012 Strength Of Schedule (http://www.theredzone.org/Features/NFLStrengthofSchedule.aspx)

TOTALLY

21st hardest

[Chaddie84]

yep...just forget the fact that the Lions have played one of the toughest schedules in the NFL.

no need to factor that in ;) :rolleyes: :)!

It also would help if Pettigrew didn't have Alligator arms.

[JoshHamilton]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. RG3

[creamybeige]

1. Tom Brady
2. Peyton Manning
3. Drew Brees
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. RG3

what?!? no Andrew luck???

nuthugger :eek:

[bdubs3316]

2012 Strength Of Schedule (http://www.theredzone.org/Features/NFLStrengthofSchedule.aspx)

TOTALLY

21st hardest

based on 2011 stats...

2011 has nothing to do with how teams are playing in 2012 :eek:

The teams they have or will play this year, so far have a record of 126-96

[Astronix]

Here are mine in order of worst to 5th worst.

1. Cardinals QB (No specific Name Needed.)
2. Blaine Gabbert
3. Jake Locker
4. Matt Cassel
5. Christian Ponder

Honorable Mention: Sanchez. He would be #6.

I think of these 6 only Ponder will start every game next year. Gabbert is done, I think Locker will get benched/replaced by Bud Adams (He tried very hard this year with Peyton), Cassel is done. Cardinals will sign a free agent/trade/draft another QB.

Don't know why the Jets don't just let Tebow or McElroy start the last two games and see what each can do. One of these two guys will start for the Jets next year.

[JoshHamilton]

what?!? no Andrew luck???

nuthugger :eek:

I'm an Eagles fan. We have no idea how to evaluate talent

[JoshHamilton]

I think of these 6 only Ponder will start every game next year. Gabbert is done, I think Locker will get benched/replaced by Bud Adams (He tried very hard this year with Peyton), Cassel is done. Cardinals will sign a free agent/trade/draft another QB.

Don't know why the Jets don't just let Tebow or McElroy start the last two games and see what each can do. One of these two guys will start for the Jets next year.

You really think Bud Adams can do a better job under center than Locker? Bud is getting up there in age, so mobility may be an issue. I definitely think he's more accurate on deep balls than Locker, though

[Seanathan297]

1. Lindley/Skelton
2. Mark Sanchez
3. Christian Ponder
4. Quinn/Cassel
5. Jake Locker

If he was still a starter, Blaine Gabbert would slot at #3

[jataman2612]

How is Weeden only on 1 of these lists?!?!

1. Ponder
2. Skelton/Lindley
3. Sanchez
4. Weeden
5. Quinn/Cassel

[obadger]

Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Ponder
Ponder

[yalcos4]

Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Ponder
Ponder

more like..

Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Gabbert

[creamybeige]

more like..

Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Sanchez
Gabbert

STARTING qbs

[CardCollector]

Worst - Brady Quinn / Cassel
2. Lindley/Skelton
3.Sanchez/Tebow
4.Gabbert/Henne
5.Fitpatrick

[Army19K]

based on 2011 stats...

2011 has nothing to do with how teams are playing in 2012 :eek:

The teams they have or will play this year, so far have a record of 126-96

Stafford, who I would no longer consider a top 10-15 QB this year, is not in the bottom 5, some people just love to hate I guess :)!

[DetectiveChrome]

Tebow
Sanchez
Cassel
Vick
Ponder

[RedSoxFan28]

1. Sanchez
2. Sanchez
3. Cardinals QB
4. Ponder
5. Luck

[scotts]

1 mark sanchez (the worst hands down)
2 arizona crew
3 quinn/cassell
4 blaine gabbert
5 ryan leaf...err....

i don't consider ponder bottom 5 qb. when percy harvin was healthy he was actually putting up good numbers

[freethrowtommy]

yep...just forget the fact that the Lions have played one of the toughest schedules in the NFL. or that they've played statistically the toughest defenses this year...

no need to factor that in ;) :rolleyes: :)!

Played the same defenses as Rodgers... he doesn't look like complete #@#@#@#@.

Still wouldn't put him in my bottom 5... but he also wouldn't be in my top 15.

[bdubs3316]

Played the same defenses as Rodgers... he doesn't look like complete #@#@#@#@.

Still wouldn't put him in my bottom 5... but he also wouldn't be in my top 15.

but remember...Rodgers is the step brother of Tebow and Jesus :)! :eek:

[Astronix]

Now Tebow < Sanchez < Greg McElroy.

[wegoingsizzler]

after last night:

1.sanchez
2.sanchez
3.sanchez
4.sanchez
5.sanchez

1 for each turnover he made last night!!! LOL!!!

[freethrowtommy]

but remember...Rodgers is the step brother of Tebow and Jesus :)! :eek:

I don't even think Jesus blood could make Tebow good...

[bdubs3316]

I don't even think Jesus blood could make Tebow good...

either way...i know there are several people here that no matter what Stafford does/did, they would still think he's horrible.

i cant and wont try to change anyone's opinion...

[creamybeige]

either way...i know there are several people here that no matter what Stafford does/did, they would still think he's horrible.

i cant and wont try to change anyone's opinion...

not true, if he played well I would definitely compliment him, right now he is playing awful...

I feel as bad for Calvin as I do for Larry Fitzgerald :eek:

[bdubs3316]

not true, if he played well I would definitely compliment him, right now he is playing awful...

I feel as bad for Calvin as I do for Larry Fitzgerald :eek:

Asinine!!!

Calvin is getting his numbers!!!

Stafford is struggling due to no one else stepping up and the o-line allowing pressure

[azviking101]

Vick's no longer a starter.

Yeah and neither is Sanchez or Skelton. But he was and is still horrible

[Krayzie83]

1- Sanchez
2- Arizona
3- Gabbert
4- KC
5- Weeden

[peytonmanning18]

1. Cardinals QB
2. The Sanchize
3. Ponder
4. Gabbert
5. Chiefs QB

[MarshallCutler6]

Sanchez
Cardinals
Gabbert
Locker
Cheifs

[peytonmanning18]

1 mark sanchez (the worst hands down)
2 arizona crew
3 quinn/cassell
4 blaine gabbert
5 ryan leaf...err....

i don't consider ponder bottom 5 qb. when percy harvin was healthy he was actually putting up good numbers

His numbers with Harvin aren't awful but his throws to Harvin were rarely over 5 yards.

[PocketPool]

Worst to First
Mark SancheZ
Christian Ponder
Jake Locker
Blaine Gabbert
Ryan Lindley (might not be here if O-Line was halfway decent)

[pfb11]

1. Lindley/Skelton (Whisenhunt = 2nd worst HC behind Romeo)
2. Sanchez (You can put McElroy here once he starts)
3. Gabbert (Although, technically he was benched)
4. Quinn (but I don't think Cassel is bottom 5)
5. Fitzpatrick (because you can count on a 4th qtr INT every week)

[KevJo]

Ponder

TD
14
INT
12
YDS
2,527
RTG
78.6


Gabbert

TDS
9
INT
6
YDS
1,662
RTG
77.4

Gabbert hasnt played in 4-5 games since being shelved. So many willing to put Gabbert up there but not Ponder. No MJD, struggling O Line and only one really good receiver. Playing injured.

Ponder Great O Line, The Best RB this year running the ball.

I have to think Gabbert would have had at least another 700+ Yards and 4-5 TD's.

I am in no way saying either was having a great season. But I like Gabbert and I think he will come out strong in camp next year regardless if they draft another passer or sign Tebow! He is younger than Luck and will only be 23 in his third year. Something to consider when leaving Ponder off that list!

Kevin

[allday_vikes]

1 mark sanchez (the worst hands down)
2 arizona crew
3 quinn/cassell
4 blaine gabbert
5 ryan leaf...err....

i don't consider ponder bottom 5 qb. when percy harvin was healthy he was actually putting up good numbers

Guess you havent seen Ponder play much. Take away Harvin's yards after the catch and Ponder probably have 20 yards passing. When you watch Ponder and Sanchez play, you see a lot of similarities there.

[johnprovenzano]

Its great the all of the top rookies drafted arent on these lists just being in their first year...no luck griffin wilson tannehill/weeden(for the most part) mentioned.

Feels like the NFL is headed in a great direction