Replacements in from Panini. How did they do???

[TKCards]

I had 4 redemptions that were overdue and asked for replacements of either another card of the same player, Packers or Patriots if possible. Listed are the redemptions and then the replacements for each. Thoughts??
Thanks, TK

Redemptions:
1. 2012 Certified- Michael Egnew- Mirror Blue Jersey/Ball/Shoe #/49
2. 2012 Certified- Ronnie Hillman- Freshman Fabric #/499
3. 2012 Prominence- Ronnie Hillman- Jersey Prime Auto #/210
4. 2012 Certified- Ronnie Hillman- FOTG Jersey/Auto Die Cut #/25


Replacements:
1. 2012 Certified- Stephen Hill- Mirror Blue Jersey/Ball/ 2 Clr Shoe # 26/49
2. 2012 Absolute- Nick Perry- Gold Spectrum Auto # 292/299
3. 2012 Panini Black- Ronnie Hillman- 3 Clr Patch Gold Ink Auto # 076/349
4. 2011 Panini Playbook- Shane Vereen- 3 Clr Patch Auto Booklet # 265/399

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v161/TKCards/bcb714e2-d946-4d4f-adb6-81de58a318be_zps0e82a3cd.jpg (http://smg.photobucket.com/user/TKCards/media/bcb714e2-d946-4d4f-adb6-81de58a318be_zps0e82a3cd.jpg.html)

[D J Sportscards]

I think you did very well especially on Egnew for hill!

[pfb11]

Yeah, pretty good.

[TKCards]

IMO- Any replacement for Egnew is a step up.