Fair Replacement?

[DwightWall122]

12-13 Blake Griffin Limited Spotlight Signatures Auto EXCH /25

gets replaced with

10-11 John Wall Contenders Manufactured Patch Auto RC (#201)

http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/k522/DwightWall122/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/th_IMG24_zps71cb1084.jpg (http://s1114.photobucket.com/user/DwightWall122/media/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/IMG24_zps71cb1084.jpg.html)

UPDATE: Received the J.Wall replacement from Panini in the mail on (5/28/13) and I was quite disappointed with the Autograph. There was a smear in the W that ran into the A, and the bottom of the autograph was cut off completely! You could barely tell that it's a #2! Is this grounds for me to send it back and get another in better conditions? Thoughts?


UPDATE 2: Sent the card back to Panini and David Sharpe went ahead and took care of everything. It was replaced with one in better conditions, and the new one looks wayy better! Scan Updated!

[kobe824]

I'd rather have Wall

[Yaga]

Fair replacement I think! Wall would probably sell for a bit more I think... Blake's stuff is coming down a lot right now.

[DwightWall122]

I'd rather have Wall

Fair replacement I think! Wall would probably sell for a bit more I think... Blake's stuff is coming down a lot right now.

Thanks for the quick opinions, I went ahead and took the replacement. The Wall is on it's way via FedEx + I did not have this Wall in my PC so I'm ok with it. :D

[EMD34]

Yeah, that is fair. I think the wall sells for more than the Blake.

[Nyfancam01]

yea and wall is WALLIN' next year! haha imagine what he could do with an actual decent team

[Beavers98]

Yeah looks Fair to me

[sotexcollector]

A healthy Wall + rookie card = better deal...

[DwightWall122]

UPDATE: Received the J.Wall replacement from Panini in the mail today (5/28/13) and I am quite disappointed with the Autograph. There is a smear in the W that runs into the A, and the bottom of the autograph is cut off completely! You can barely tell that it's a #2! Is this grounds for me to send it back and get another in better conditions? Thoughts Please?

http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/k522/DwightWall122/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/th_IMG_0006_zpsc35088ba.jpg (http://s1114.photobucket.com/user/DwightWall122/media/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/IMG_0006_zpsc35088ba.jpg.html)

[drob50]

UPDATE: Received the J.Wall replacement from Panini in the mail today (5/28/13) and I am quite disappointed with the Autograph. There is a smear in the W that runs into the A, and the bottom of the autograph is cut off completely! You can barely tell that it's a #2! Is this grounds for me to send it back and get another in better conditions? Thoughts Please?

http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/k522/DwightWall122/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/th_IMG_0006_zpsc35088ba.jpg (http://s1114.photobucket.com/user/DwightWall122/media/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/IMG_0006_zpsc35088ba.jpg.html)

No. That is just how some cards are! :)!

[jumbogorilla]

send it back. send with a letter explaining the situation and ask for something else if you don't want wall. i found them to be reasonably easy to work with.

[DwightWall122]

send it back. send with a letter explaining the situation and ask for something else if you don't want wall. i found them to be reasonably easy to work with.

I don't mind a J.Wall as a replacement, I just don't like the condition of the autograph at all. I will contact them tomorrow and see what I can do. Thanks!

[DwightWall122]

UPDATE: Sent the card back to Panini and David Sharpe went ahead and took care of everything. It was replaced with one in better conditions, and the new one looks wayy better! Scan Updated!

http://i1114.photobucket.com/albums/k522/DwightWall122/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/th_IMG24_zps71cb1084.jpg (http://s1114.photobucket.com/user/DwightWall122/media/PC%20NFT%20NBA/NBA%20PC/IMG24_zps71cb1084.jpg.html)

[theautographkid]

Nice card. You got a fair replacement as well