UD Replacement Mailday

[Mcpug]

In 2009 I pulled a redemption for a John Stockton/Deron Williams Signature Shots dual auto /15 out of 07-08 Sweet Shot. Ive been waiting forever since then for a replacement, and finally started calling them bi-weekly starting in March. According to Upper Deck they mailed something out 2 months ago but I never received it and they didn't have a tracking number. So they said they would send me something again. I requested an NBA uniform card since that's what the redemption was for. I guess I'm a little happy as I'm a Rose fan, just wish it was in an NBA uniform. They also sent a card that was what the Stockton and Williams was supposed to be, but it was TJ Ford and Daniel Gibson instead lol.

What do you guys think? Fair replacement?

http://i440.photobucket.com/albums/qq126/McPUG/Basketball/ford.jpg

http://i440.photobucket.com/albums/qq126/McPUG/Basketball/roseauto-1.jpg

[samuel1219]

I really don't like that replacement, the rose is OK but /149 and the gibson ford auto is an insult replacement for a Stockton/Williams. But just my opinion.

[vikingfan101]

I think you got shorted as well. Rose isn't bad but as said its college uni. I would guess the Dual would have been $150-$200 card. Rose is like 75? $5 on other dual.

[lb_sa]

I don't think that's too bad.

[pingbling23]

i dont think there is anyway that stockton/deron would have been a 150-200 card, here is a nice dual oncard auto of stockton and d. robinson that sold for $77 2003 04 UD SP Authentic Signatures John Stockton and David Robinson Dual Autos | eBay (http://www.ebay.com/itm/2003-04-UD-SP-Authentic-Signatures-John-Stockton-and-David-Robinson-dual-Autos-/221228755805?pt=US_Autographed_Trading_Cards&hash=item338242eb5d&nma=true&si=KjRSBQ73y0hT7miegLAvchQxGfg%253D&orig_cvip=true&rt=nc&_trksid=p2047675.l2557). the rose isnt a bad replacement, the dual they sent is weak. i wonder what they had originally sent you?

[Roymunson]

I'd rather have what the redemption was for. Should have stated players you were seeking

[xavieronly1]

I think you can a little less (like $10 less). And it is weird for UD to send you a $2 auto to make up the pricing difference. It is like UD is trying to send you a $50 card + 20 x $1 GU for a $70 replacement.

[Nsingerma11]

Those sweet shot are awful to me...I think it seems OK...

[Mcpug]

Yea, I'm not sure what to think. I am a Bulls fan and do like Rose, I'm just not a fan of letterman or college stuff. I wish I could find out what they sent me first. I kind of wondered if they actually sent something out to be honest. I was bugging them so much and then one guy on the phone said they sent something, and when I asked for a tracking number, he said they didn't send with tracking. And I think they threw in the dual auto just to show what I should have gotten lol, it's not a coincidence that I got that card and my redemption was from the same set.

So what would you guys do? Send em back and try to get something better or just be content. It took about 4 years to get this far, don't know if I want to drag it on any further.