3 Part Discussion Thread......

[manning99]

Always like hearing board members comments on topics like this....

1. One card under $20 you have always wanted but never been able to find

2. One player, under no circumstances, that you would ever PC...catch is he has to have had at least 3 years in the league....no scrubs....

3. Your ultimate 10 Living Players you would have sign on card autos for a special redemption card in 2013 National Treasures to receive all 10 (I'd love to see a redemption card inserted for complete autograph sets)

Have fun,
Brad

[ekalbnz]

Should be some interesting answers!

1. This card I have been chasing since it was released and never seen one pop up anywhere (including ebay) I am assuming because it is a retail exclusive. I would love to get my hands on a 2012 Absolute Spectrum Black Miles Burris #d/25. I'm probably the only person around that wants one of these!

2. "that you would ever PC". I am assuming you meant never! Pretty easy: Tom Brady.

3. Jared Veldheer, Stefen Wisniewski, Steve Wisniewski, Art Shell, Jim Otto, Howie Long, Greg Biekert, Charles Woodson, Jack Tatum and Phil Villapiano (all in Raiders uniform)

[usaf010]

1. N/A

2. Suh (Detriot Lions)

3. Ultimate on card booklet auto for me would be:

Brian Urlacher
Mike Ditka
Dick Butkis
Mike Singletary
Walter Payton
Brandon Marshall
Devin Hester
Alshon Jeffery
Jay Cutler
Lance Briggs

[ssbledsoe]

1) Matt Slater 2008 Bowman Chrome Orange /25

2) Ben Roethlisberger because he's a Rapey McDouchenoozle

3) Pats HOFers:
Tedy Bruschi
Troy Brown
Drew Bledsoe
Ben Coates
Stanley Morgan
Andre Tippett
John Hannah
Nick Buoniconti
Mike Haynes
Tom Brady (not yet enshrined)

[usaf010]

2) Ben Roethlisberger because he's a Rapey McDouchenoozle

Hah! Thanks for the laugh. :)!

[Herr Sparkz]

Always like hearing board members comments on topics like this....

1. One card under $20 you have always wanted but never been able to find

2. One player, under no circumstances, that you would ever PC...catch is he has to have had at least 3 years in the league....no scrubs....

3. Your ultimate 10 Living Players you would have sign on card autos for a special redemption card in 2013 National Treasures to receive all 10 (I'd love to see a redemption card inserted for complete autograph sets)

Have fun,
Brad

I definitely would have bolded this just to make sure people read it

[yourmyboyblue2]

1. One card under $20 you have always wanted but never been able to find

1990 Panini Stickers UK Barry Sanders(all 3, have yet to see one)

2. One player, under no circumstances, that you would ever PC...catch is he has to have had at least 3 years in the league....no scrubs....

Tom Brady

3. Your ultimate 10 Living Players you would have sign on card autos for a special redemption card in 2013 National Treasures to receive all 10 (I'd love to see a redemption card inserted for complete autograph sets)

Barry Sanders, Jim Brown, Dan Marino, Peyton Manning, Jerry Rice, Randy Moss, Mike Singletary, Lawrence Taylor, Ronnie Lott, Ray Guy

Or

Lee Evans, Ron Dayne, Chris Chambers, Joe Thomas, Montee Ball, Al Toon, Nick Toon, Troy Vincent, JJ Watt, Owen Daniels

or

Lawrence Phillips, Rae Carruth, Dave Meggett, Darryl Henely, Eric Naposki, Robert Rozier, Keith Wright, Stanley Wilson, Art Schlichter, Sam Hurd

[Verufian]

1) 1999 Topps Stadium Club Brock Huard First Day Issue Chrome Refractors #/25
2) RGIII (less than 3 years) or Eli Manning
3) Jim Zorn, Dave Kreig, Matt Hasselbeck, Russell Wilson, Shaun Alexander, Marshawn Lynch, Curt Warner, John L Williams, Michael Robinson, Steve Largent.

[ekalbnz]

Lawrence Phillips, Rae Carruth, Dave Meggett, Darryl Henely, Eric Naposki, Robert Rozier, Keith Wright, Stanley Wilson, Art Schlichter, Sam Hurd

How could you leave Aaron Hernadez off that list?!? :)!

[nibrugnerotto]

1. Justin Tucker Score Black /6. It sold for $6 before I made the decision to collect him:(

2. Butt Fumble Sanchez

3. I only have 9 Players:
John David Booty
Dick Butkus
Guy Whimper
Demarcus Faggins
Lucious Pusey
Ben Gay
Anthony Midget
Fair Hooker
Josh Booty

How awesome would it be for the names on your card to be "Gay, Midget, Hooker, Booty":D

[Seahawks fan]

Card $25 and under - 2003 Marcus Trufant Topps Pristine Rare rc Gold refractor/25 .. Had a chance to get one off Beckett.com for $25 about 4 years ago but someone pulled the trigger before me and I havnt seen one since..

I would never PC Big Ben.. his nose looks too much like the one Dan Akroyd had in the movie Nothing But Trouble.

10 Auto booklet
Walter Jones Russel Wilson
Cortez Kennedy Richard Sherman
Kenny Easley Kam Chancellor
Jacob Green Earl Thomas
Steve Largent Pete Carrol

[88horsepower]

Always like hearing board members comments on topics like this....

1. One card under $20 you have always wanted but never been able to find


I could name a bunch of inserts from the 1990s (e.g. 1996 Skybox Rubies comes to mind). However, for the sake of this discussion, I have never been able to track down a 1999 Playoff Contenders Speed Red Terrence Wilkins http://i302.photobucket.com/albums/nn120/88horsepower/1_afcecc60cd9a0091720f91f2aa5bf515_zps3b60efdb.jpg

Aggravates the hell out of me, too. Should be a $10 card, but I'll be damned if I can find one.


2. One player, under no circumstances, that you would ever PC...catch is he has to have had at least 3 years in the league....no scrubs....


Since I only PC Colts, I can't imagine this happening. However, if I ever expanded by collection to non-rookies I would not likely want to collect anything of Jay Cutler. Can't stand that guy.


3. Your ultimate 10 Living Players you would have sign on card autos for a special redemption card in 2013 National Treasures to receive all 10 (I'd love to see a redemption card inserted for complete autograph sets)

Ooooooh, great question, man.

1996 NFL Draft Flashback Card:

Keyshawn Johnson
Marvin Harrison
Terrell Owens
Muhsin Muhammad
Eric Moulds
Bobby Engram
Joe Horn
Terry Glenn
Eddie Kennison
Amani Toomer