If you could buy one... Which would it be?

[BrewCrewBall27]

Wondering which one of the two cards you would buy. Any input would be greatly appreciated. I'm leaning towards EJ, but living in MN I think I could get a lot in return for CPatt

[jcduncan]

EJ Manuel NT

[player fly]

CPatt for sure.

[trixstar]

EJ
10 characters

[BrewCrewBall27]

CPatt for sure.

Even with the $15 price difference? Any explanation would help! Also looks like EJ would shatter it in ebay prices.

[jcduncan]

Even with the $15 price difference? Any explanation would help!

He's a Patterson collector lol

[codyc99]

I would go with the EJ.

[packerfan4200]

In a situation like this you always, always go with the QB over a WR. Only one has the potential to increase in value if that's what you're concerned about.

[trixstar]

The last EJ /49 sold at auction yesterday for for 204.00.

[bballcollector]

Patterson for sure.

[MeetJSquared]

EJ, no question. I think he has a higher price ceiling (as with most QBs) as far as card value.

[Joe]

In a situation like this you always, always go with the QB over a WR. Only one has the potential to increase in value if that's what you're concerned about.

^^^^ this. Even if EJ struggles you could still sell it for a bit, even guys like Matt Leinart still get $ for their cards. Look at WR's who fall and their cards are worthless... Roy Williams, etc. Go with EJ, he will do well this year.

[player fly]

Even with the $15 price difference? Any explanation would help! Also looks like EJ would shatter it in ebay prices.

If your looking to flip go with EJ. Just thought a mn guy would rather have a CPatt auto lol.

[Rhyster66]

EJ for suuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuure.

[asujbl]

Always the QB

[stripedbass91]

In a situation like this you always, always go with the QB over a WR. Only one has the potential to increase in value if that's what you're concerned about.

Couldnt agree more.

[BrewCrewBall27]

If your looking to flip go with EJ. Just thought a mn guy would rather have a CPatt auto lol.

I'm a packers collector though haha.

[packerfan4200]

I'm a packers collector though haha.

And a badger and brewer fan as well I see:)!

[MW Connection]

NT of them only sell for that much lol. Boxes should be like 150

[BrewCrewBall27]

And a badger and brewer fan as well I see:)!

you know it!

[sportscardmania]

Always the QB

So Jarmacus Russell over Calvin Johnson or AP? The Raiders made that choice. :D

[BrewCrewBall27]

So Jarmacus Russell over Calvin Johnson or AP? The Raiders made that choice. :D

I'm pretty sure that EJ Manuel has proved more through an injury season than Jamarcus did his whole life.

[CARDFR33K]

neither .... lol

[BrewCrewBall27]

neither .... lol

where would you rather put your money?

[BrewCrewBall27]

UPDATE: I decided to go with the EJ
http://sportscardalbum.com/c/7r3oxwk3.jpeg

[sportscards0513]

Great choice!

[twisty571]

So Jarmacus Russell over Calvin Johnson or AP? The Raiders made that choice. :D

http://www.quickmeme.com/img/39/39f15354a6561dc9f3578813cadeee2aba75dee6b0b031f3ff9e213eeb4b8134.jpg


OP nice score!

[BrewCrewBall27]

Great choice!

http://www.quickmeme.com/img/39/39f15354a6561dc9f3578813cadeee2aba75dee6b0b031f3ff9e213eeb4b8134.jpg


OP nice score!

thanks guys!!! I feel like I got a really good deal! Should i flip now and make like 50-65 bucks or hold for season?

[GOWIFB]

Nice choice on the EJ. And as others have mentioned, usually you go with the QB over a WR, especially a WR who is in Minnesota. If he played for the Packers, Patriots, Broncos, etc then I would maybe go with them, but look who is throwing him the ball in Minnesota (actually we dont know who is throwing him the ball cause they dont have a QB selected yet lol). Look what happened to our friend Greg Jennings when he went to Minnesota. He is a very good receiver but just dropped off the map.

[lagalaxyfan23]

thanks guys!!! I feel like I got a really good deal! Should i flip now and make like 50-65 bucks or hold for season?

Hold it. I wonder where you got that EJ, because I'd buy them all day for $135 a piece haha. EJ's going to tear it up this season with Sammy, and since his prices are literally at pretty much rock bottom right now for whatever reason, it's a great time to buy.

[MeetJSquared]

Hold it. I wonder where you got that EJ, because I'd buy them all day for $135 a piece haha. EJ's going to tear it up this season with Sammy, and since his prices are literally at pretty much rock bottom right now for whatever reason, it's a great time to buy.

It was from SportsCardsDirect (link is under the pic OP posted). I saw it the other day, and almost pulled the trigger, but I wanted a /99. And then I saw the Cordarrelle on there as well. So that's where he saw both.

[BrewCrewBall27]

It was from SportsCardsDirect (link is under the pic OP posted). I saw it the other day, and almost pulled the trigger, but I wanted a /99. And then I saw the Cordarrelle on there as well. So that's where he saw both.

Yep that website is great.

[Devi8or]

I would have taken the EJ as well, I know it's been stated, but the QB>WR almost always holds true.

Could it work out opposite? Ansolutely, but the QB upside is so much greater