Need help getting an idea what these cards are worth. Please Help!

[CardScout]

Alright, thanks for looking and any help you can offer would be greatly appreciated. The first card I traded $600 worth of cards for because the trader told me he got the value for it from beckett online and it was worth $1,200. You tell me what you think. Thanks

http://i1362.photobucket.com/albums/r693/JesseBoeglin/Personal%20Collection/Joe-Montana-Book-5-5_zps57d3fe68.jpg (http://s1362.photobucket.com/user/JesseBoeglin/media/Personal%20Collection/Joe-Montana-Book-5-5_zps57d3fe68.jpg.html)

This next one I am in the process of trading for but I tend to wonder if I might be trading to much for it. Please let me know what you think a fair trade value is. I love the card and would love to trade for it but I just don't know what it is worth. After recently finding out the Montana might not even be worth half or a third what I traded for it I wanted to get some advise before I acted. Please take into consideration that the trader is figuring the value of the cards I am trading off the average of the listed ebays sales and deducting for less colors on the patch ect.

OK I KNOW I GOT HOSED ON THE MONTANA BUT WHATS THE MANNING WORTH IN TRADE? I NEED TO KNOW SO I DON'T GET HOSED AGAIN!
http://i1362.photobucket.com/albums/r693/JesseBoeglin/Baseball/Peyton-Manning-Plate-Auto_zpsc2f60495.jpg (http://s1362.photobucket.com/user/JesseBoeglin/media/Baseball/Peyton-Manning-Plate-Auto_zpsc2f60495.jpg.html)
PLEASE GIVE ME AN IDEA OF WHAT YOU THINK THIS ONE IS WORTH/HOW MUCH IN TRADE VALUE WOULD YOU GIVE FOR IT?
Any help you can offer would be greatly appreciated!

[Samiamryan]

2013 Topps Five Star Joe Montana Signature Book Card Auto Triple Jersey 38 | eBay (http://www.ebay.com/itm/2013-Topps-Five-Star-Joe-Montana-Signature-Book-Card-Auto-Triple-Jersey-38-/261591189730?pt=US_Football&hash=item3ce80cc8e2)

Stop trading with the other guy....

[phinzphan1372]

The first card I traded $600 worth of cards for because the trader told me he got the value for it from beckett online and it was worth $1,200.

First off... awesome cards..... just a FYI ... beckett usually does not list prices of print runs that low... dunno a value on it ... but its nice either way :)

[Bostonsports1]

Ouch, you got hosed on that Montana

[james050713]

The manning is 1/1 $4-600 ish the montana 2-300 ish I stress the ish u did get burned on it

[89transam]

yikes dude you got swindled

[gamer4l1fe]

That Montana is not even remotely close to a 1200 hundred dollar card. Just because it's pretty doesn't mean it's worth the farm LOL!!!! You got hosed in the worst way dude sorry about that. The sad thing is the Manning is not half as pretty of a card and is worth twice as much or more.

[CardScout]

Thanks guys, can anyone give me an idea what the Manning is worth? PRETTY PLEASE!!

[JosieD]

What cards did you trade him for the Montana?

[gamer4l1fe]

The manning is 1/1 $4-600 ish the montana 2-300 ish I stress the ish u did get burned on it

I think he gave you a pretty good estimate of both cards values. I think the Montana might be on the lower end of the estimate and the Manning somewhere in the middle. But right around those ranges either way if you ask me.

[CardScout]

What cards did you trade him for the Montana?

I know 3 Wilson Auto's were involved, A sick Eddy Lacy Prime Book with the jumbo hat relic /5, a Rogers NT Auto, a Moss Rookie auto, and a few other mid end cards.

[CubKings]

I know 3 Wilson Auto's were involved, A sick Eddy Lacy Prime Book with the jumbo hat relic /5, a Rogers NT Auto, a Moss Rookie auto, and a few other mid end cards.

OOOOOUCH....

[cyndeeg3]

I know 3 Wilson Auto's were involved, A sick Eddy Lacy Prime Book with the jumbo hat relic /5, a Rogers NT Auto, a Moss Rookie auto, and a few other mid end cards.

Hope you are kidding or exaggerating or mis-remembering.

On that note - wanna trade?

[CardScout]

What cards did you trade him for the Montana?

Way to much I know now. but I need to know about the Manning so it doesn't happen again!

[Samiamryan]

Way to much I know now. but I need to know about the Manning so it doesn't happen again!

Manning would sell for $300ish

[CardScout]

The manning is 1/1 $4-600 ish the montana 2-300 ish I stress the ish u did get burned on it

I would have to wonder if the Manning is worth that much I had another member show me it didn't sell when he listed it on ebay for $379 a couple months ago so I can't think it is worth more than that just how much less than that is the question? Also that was before Brady handed his a$$ to him.

[Samiamryan]

I know 3 Wilson Auto's were involved, A sick Eddy Lacy Prime Book with the jumbo hat relic /5, a Rogers NT Auto, a Moss Rookie auto, and a few other mid end cards.

Whoever traded with you is not your friend. This is wrong on so many levels. One of these cards would have been a fair trade. Seriously, this is so wrong. Stay away from this guy and dont trade for the Manning. He is just going to screw you again.

[Rule]

Was the trader a member here?

[CardScout]

Was the trader a member here?

Yeah and it was his avatar until he traded it to me but that is all I want to say about that.

[CardScout]

The manning is 1/1 $4-600 ish the montana 2-300 ish I stress the ish u did get burned on it

Aside from the Montana, the numbers you gave me were the numbers I was hoping to get because once again I am going to have to give some of my finer cards to get it. The only reason I question your estimate is because there have been 2 recent sales of Manning Plates on ebay one sold for $270 and the other sold for $450 but they both have multi color patches and the second was his 2013 National Treasures patch auto which I would think is about the best plate auto's you could get for him. In addition I was sent some info from a another member showing the Absolute Manning had been listed a few times on ebay in the past with no interest and at it lowest it was listed for $379 with the payment plan option available but it didn't sell. $450 is what he is looking for in trade which by your calculations seams like a fair deal and at first when I saw it I thought so to because I collect and tend to over value printing plates. I recently found out they don't sell very well or for as much as I have been thinking. The only reason why I started this thread was in hopes I would find a lot of members agreeing with you and if anything maybe leaning towards the $600 because the cards he wants in trade are some of the nicer cards I have in my bucket and he wants to give me the low average of the ebay sale prices that have listed in return for my cards which ordinarily I wouldn't mind but I kind of have a problem with it seeing as how he isn't doing the average for the last sales for his card to. Which I think would be fair since not only is one of them one of the better plates available but they both have multi color patches. Am I looking at this wrong? Also I appreciate all the info but I already understand I got hosed on the Montana so please try to stick to the Manning in your responses. Thanks

[adamblumy]

Oh my...the card in your avatar :eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:

[CardScout]

Oh my...the card in your avatar :eek::eek::eek::eek::eek:

Thanks, just got it in a break a couple days ago. It was one of the best days of my life and absolutely the best break of my life. I couldn't be happier with it. The best part is I needed a Emmitt Smith Auto for my collection.

[adamblumy]

Thanks, just got it in a break a couple days ago. It was one of the best days of my life and absolutely the best break of my life. I couldn't be happier with it. The best part is I needed a Emmitt Smith Auto for my collection.

Very sick congrats. Sorry to be random on this thread in which you got hosed, but congrats on that sickness.

[CardScout]

Any input today?>

[jlzinck]

Serious question....Are you older than 18?

[CardScout]

Serious question....Are you older than 18?

Really? Yeah why does that effect your response?

[Ray27Ray52]

The Manning is a $300 card on a good day. That Montana is maybe $250 and that would be stretching it imo.

That trader absolutely owned you sorry to say. You got hosed big time.

[jlzinck]

Really? Yeah why does that effect your response?

Because if you were a child I might have felt sorry for you.

[Anthonylp1985]

Was the trader a member here?

[FOR SALE] 2013 Five Star Joe Montana Booklet Auto 5/5 (http://www.sportscardforum.com/threads/2092908-2013-Five-Star-Joe-Montana-Booklet-Auto-5-5)


FT/FS 2013 Five Star Joe Montana Book 5/5 - The Cardboard Connection Forum (http://community.cardboardconnection.com/forums/football-marketplace/78145-ft-fs-2013-five-star-joe-montana-book-5-5-a.html)

Maybe?