Which BGS 9 MJ RC would YOU rather have?

[MJKOBE2324]

Ok so PWCC has this BGS 9 MJ RC going live right now

Subs 3x9.5 and one 8.5 on the surface..

1986 Fleer Basketball Michael Jordan Rookie RC 57 BGS 9 Mint PWCC | eBay (http://www.ebay.com/itm/1986-Fleer-Basketball-Michael-Jordan-ROOKIE-RC-57-BGS-9-MINT-PWCC-/141629522352?pt=LH_DefaultDomain_0&hash=item20f9c701b0)

And I own the card below. BGS 9 with subs 10 centering, 9.5 edges, and two 9's


I ask this "which would you rather?" question because I bought mine for 2400 4 years ago and I see that the PWCC auction might end around 3k possibly? So it got me wondering, which BGS 9 would you rather have? Which do you think is the more likely if going head 2 head to win the end price war?

Here is my card with NO 8.5's to be found... BUT... Only two subs 9.5 or above as opposed to 3 in PWCC's... Let me know if you can. Just curious. Thanks so much.

http://i786.photobucket.com/albums/yy149/benmoss81/JORDANBGS9MINE_zpsb41d71b4.jpg (http://s786.photobucket.com/user/benmoss81/media/JORDANBGS9MINE_zpsb41d71b4.jpg.html)

[hairyangryfella]

I don't like your top left corner, but the 10 for centering is probably more appealing for people. Pretty even but I'd lean towards yours.

[GC1980]

10 centering all the way. Great card.

[exoticprince]

Given I own a 10 centred one myself I'm going with yours :D

[ThoseBackPages]

T/B centering is off on theirs.

Yours wins

[thecomebacker]

Centering dominates, so yours win. But yours will never get PWCC prices if you know what I mean.

[JasonM32]

T/B centering is off on theirs.



And it has a rough edge.

[bullard123]

Centering dominates, so yours win. But yours will never get PWCC prices if you know what I mean.

I dont get why people pay more for the card since PWCC lists it? Am I missing something?

[marquis930]

It's tough to beat 10 Centering, especially since everything else on your card is 9+.

[MJKOBE2324]

Thanks guys for your thoughts and opinions.

HairyAngry- It's just from the scan. That top left corner is sharp.

Yo exoticprince... Maybe i'm looking for an excuse for you to shows yours off again LOL!

I wonder what a BGS 9 with 10 centering would go for in today's market. Maybe one day I'll try and upgrade by selling mine and using the money towards a 9.5! Then I'll get the answer to my question lol


Anyone else have opinions on which they'd rather have and which would have a bigger final sale price?


Thanks again

[MJKOBE2324]

Top left corner HairyAngryFella

http://i786.photobucket.com/albums/yy149/benmoss81/Mobile%20Uploads/image_zps67c09947.jpg (http://s786.photobucket.com/user/benmoss81/media/Mobile%20Uploads/image_zps67c09947.jpg.html)

[pat10021839]

I would try to resubmit yours.

[dapro]

I'll rather have yours!

[MJKOBE2324]

I would try to resubmit yours.

I always kinda had a weird prejudice against doing that. It's like... I don't want a sympathy bump or a fake 9.5... BUT... I really don't get the 9 on surface? It appears gem to me under my loop lol

The corners are all sharp, but not gem sharp so I wouldn't even accept that bump... The card doesn't deserve it and if nobody else knew.. I would lol

[hairyangryfella]

Top left corner HairyAngryFella


Good stuff, it looked out of shape in your scan. In that case, definitely your one. And if the surface is actually good (on back and front) I'd think about resubmitting. Grading is stupid thesedays, two different people could have graded your card differently, depending what kind of day they were having... So you have a great #@#@#@#@ at a 9.5. That's also a risk though.

[nameanking]

Your edges look like chit.I see white all around that card. How can that be 9.5 edges

[MJKOBE2324]

Your edges look like chit.I see white all around that card. How can that be 9.5 edges

Just the scan bro. It's only got some light chipping on the top right edge. Everything else perfect... hence why it's 9.5 and not pristine. Thanks

[MJKOBE2324]

Well it ended at 2750... Not bad