Value of luck Sherman dual auto

[fduran27]

Just hit this in a box and was curious of value - didn't see any on the bay

http://i728.photobucket.com/albums/ww289/fduran27/6EA41101-5065-4D56-9E14-5B8D0002C955_zpsfjgo5tj1.jpg (http://s728.photobucket.com/user/fduran27/media/6EA41101-5065-4D56-9E14-5B8D0002C955_zpsfjgo5tj1.jpg.html)

[Chrisp253]

Prolly 200-250. Not a very big market for a card like that beyond stanford collectors as the 2 players dont have any recent history or even seem to act like they ever played with eachother.

[fduran27]

Prolly 200-250. Not a very big market for a card like that beyond stanford collectors as the 2 players dont have any recent history or even seem to act like they ever played with eachother.

Thanks - Was thinking $300.... so i am in the range.

[mainelobster]

I'd think it's a $250-$300 card. Lucks prices are through the roof and college collectors will love it.

[coltsnsox07]

Sharp card! Of course both Stanford guys know better than to sign off the sticker too!

[freethrowtommy]

That is a sweet card!

I would have thought it would go for more than $300...

[mainelobster]

That is a sweet card!

I would have thought it would go for more than $300...

Definitely could. I'm sure a set collector has been waiting to snag one. OP I'd start it at a higher BIN OBO and lower it if no solid offers. Always the only way to truly value a rare card.

[freethrowtommy]

Definitely could. I'm sure a set collector has been waiting to snag one. OP I'd start it at a higher BIN OBO and lower it if no solid offers. Always the only way to truly value a rare card.

I agree. Put it up and let the offers come in, OP.

If not, put it at 99 cents and let it ride. I have a feeling you are going to get some people on this.

[Coventry6546]

It's the only one I have seen released and as someone mentioned above, Luck prices are crazy right now and Sherman is arguably the best corner in the league right now. Some good things going on with this card, you will have the Luck collectors competing, Seahawks fans, Sherman Collectors and Stanford fans.

If it were me, I'd put it up for auction and be happy with anything over $200 (don't think you will have problem getting that). Good luck!

[Chrisp253]

It's the only one I have seen released and as someone mentioned above, Luck prices are crazy right now and Sherman is arguably the best corner in the league right now. Some good things going on with this card, you will have the Luck collectors competing, Seahawks fans, Sherman Collectors and Stanford fans.

If it were me, I'd put it up for auction and be happy with anything over $200 (don't think you will have problem getting that). Good luck!
Ehh i wouldnt touch it as a sherman and hawks collector.. no desire outside his nfl uni and 99 percent of the time i only want him on the card unless its legion of boom. Im sure many luck collectors feel the same way as his duals with other players his rookie year go considerably less even the ones with other colts.

Stanford collectors are basically where the money is gona have to come from.

Actually just looked up lucks cards from that set.. his ssp solo autos are in the 160-230 range if ya take away an outlier sale of 276 (the 230 sale was the same card but 9.5/10 vs a raw at 276 sale)

So i think im prolly pretty spot on. I dont think it would be ridiculous to see it go at 300 but myself personally feel that cards like this create a very niche market for themselves. College jersey will scare off many collectors, dual aspect will push off many pc guys.

Either way good luck with the sale and let us know what ya get!

[thenextlevel]

I'd hold it and wait n see if Indy & Seattle meet in the playoffs :D

[fduran27]

Ehh i wouldnt touch it as a sherman and hawks collector.. no desire outside his nfl uni and 99 percent of the time i only want him on the card unless its legion of boom. Im sure many luck collectors feel the same way as his duals with other players his rookie year go considerably less even the ones with other colts.

Stanford collectors are basically where the money is gona have to come from.

Actually just looked up lucks cards from that set.. his ssp solo autos are in the 160-230 range if ya take away an outlier sale of 276 (the 230 sale was the same card but 9.5/10 vs a raw at 276 sale)

So i think im prolly pretty spot on. I dont think it would be ridiculous to see it go at 300 but myself personally feel that cards like this create a very niche market for themselves. College jersey will scare off many collectors, dual aspect will push off many pc guys.

Either way good luck with the sale and let us know what ya get!


thanks again for the insight... Will probably list it this week and see if i get offers.

[fduran27]

I'd hold it and wait n see if Indy & Seattle meet in the playoffs :D

LOL - Always thinking like a CEO..
that would make this card worth $1M right?

[IronMonkey415]

No way... I think $1500 range.

[Coventry6546]

Ehh i wouldnt touch it as a sherman and hawks collector.. no desire outside his nfl uni and 99 percent of the time i only want him on the card unless its legion of boom. Im sure many luck collectors feel the same way as his duals with other players his rookie year go considerably less even the ones with other colts.

Stanford collectors are basically where the money is gona have to come from.

Actually just looked up lucks cards from that set.. his ssp solo autos are in the 160-230 range if ya take away an outlier sale of 276 (the 230 sale was the same card but 9.5/10 vs a raw at 276 sale)

So i think im prolly pretty spot on. I dont think it would be ridiculous to see it go at 300 but myself personally feel that cards like this create a very niche market for themselves. College jersey will scare off many collectors, dual aspect will push off many pc guys.

Either way good luck with the sale and let us know what ya get!

To be fair, that's because most of Lucks rookie duals were with RGIII, Blackmon and TRich. As far as Colts Duos, Fleener and Allen are alright, but nothing anyone would necessarily go out of their way to add. Would rather have Hilton then those two.

Just wouldn't want the OP to sell themselves short. College Unis don't get as much respect, but at least they were college teammates and both considered premium players at their respective positions. Again, my opinion would be to let it ride at auction and let the market decide a price rather then just throwing out an arbitrary number based on assumptions.

[Tones]

non-rookie, sticker auto's, and college uniform (and in my opinion, ugly design). no way it sells north of $350

[Andrew Jones]

non-rookie, sticker auto's, and college uniform (and in my opinion, ugly design). no way it sells north of $30

$30? I'd pay twice that without giving it a second thought so I think you're way off.

[Tones]

$30? I'd pay twice that without giving it a second thought so I think you're way off.
fixed lol :D

[mainelobster]

$399 OBO and you'll know what it's worth within a week.