Which RC would you prefer?

[bloodbath]

A 2014 Topps Platinum 2color Patch sticker Auto /50 or
A 2014 Topps Supreme on card auto /25.

Both are graded 9/10. Both are close to the same price. Player doesn't matter. But the same player on both cards.

Please advise.

[CCSportsCards]

Platinum

[huskerman47]

On card lower numbered over event worn

[Siberian13]

Supreme /25.

[Mister2Bits]

Supreme /25, unless the patch/jersey was game worn.

[socal805]

Supreme...Can't go wrong with a shorter print and a on card auto.

[goodole13]

On-card

[CCSportsCards]

I don't know the player he is talking about but I assume these are the two cards?


You guys like the Supreme over the Platinum?

Pass! Auto Patch all the way

[Bretsky]

Supreme even with the pictured cards above. Who cares if you have a patch from an "event"...

On-card auto all day long

[Seahawks fan]

Who cares if you have a patch from an "event"...


Considering all RC patch cards made in any product are from event worn. That would = every single person who collects RPAs which is most of the collecting community in some shape or form.... I would go with the patch auto since it looks more appealing... Although I prefer oncard... there are so many variation of that supreme card that they all just get lost in the fold which is why a sticker auto supereme patch outsells a Supreme Oncard non patch all day long.

[ekalbnz]

I would go with on-card lower #d every time. Only exception being if the player was in a photo shop '00' uniform or college uniform then I would think differently (but by the looks these do not apply to Supreme)

[Mikegioseffi]

I almost always like the look of a nice rpa better then just an in card auto.
Sticker or not if the patch looks nice I'd take that one.

[pazerbaijan]

2014 Supreme had a lot of corner and edge chipping issues, so I would view a BGS 9.0 from that set as a 9.5 from a fairly consistent set like Platinum. I'm not sure if that helps your decision at all.

[majestik101]

I love Platinum 2014. That would be my choice.

[Shanksampson]

Supreme even with the pictured cards above. Who cares if you have a patch from an "event"...

On-card auto all day long

Yahtzee...!!!!!!!!!!!

[DannyHultzenFan]

Platinum all day long love patch autos. Who cares if its only worn at an event. Eye appeal of cards is the way to go in my book and that card looks way better then just a base auto from supreme.

[bloodbath]

Thanks everyone for your input. So the answer is: it's a personal preference.

Let me throw one more in there...

2014 Certified Potential on card auto 9.5/10 vs the Topps cards...

[LoveItCards]

I like the look of Platinums.

[Grza]

Preme Preme Preme

[75Topps]

I would go for the /25 on card auto. The patch on the /50 is prob not even event worn.

[bloodbath]

Bought this today. Hope I didn't overpay. But glad it's on it's way.

317689

[TheVolta]

As many have said, go with the Supreme on card auto no question.
What is the appeal of a sticker auto slapped on a card with an "event" worn patch?

When you boil it down its basically just a manufactured material card with a sticker.

[bloodbath]

2014 Supreme had a lot of corner and edge chipping issues, so I would view a BGS 9.0 from that set as a 9.5 from a fairly consistent set like Platinum. I'm not sure if that helps your decision at all.

In the end it was the deal maker. The Supreme is a true Pop1 while the Platinum was a A Pop2 of many.

[hugh]

how can it be a POP 2 of many? POP 2 means there are 2...if it's many then it would be POP 30, POP 23 etc

[bloodbath]

how can it be a POP 2 of many? POP 2 means there are 2...if it's many then it would be POP 30, POP 23 etc

Grading info: You would know better than me.
What I meant was it was tied with many as the 2nd best of its kind.

Thanks for the education.

[Chaddie84]

Supreme and it's not even close for me, and I'm even one who loves shiny cards.

[bloodbath]

Supreme and it's not even close for me, and I'm even one who loves shiny cards.

Yeah. That's what I went with. Got a true Pop1 Carr RC On Card Auto /25

In bucket: Raiders PC by willgrove80 | Photobucket (http://s1030.photobucket.com/user/willgrove80/library/Raiders%20PC)