Need opinions on a couple of diamond giveaway trade offers:
 

I could really use some honest opinions on a few offers I have received.

The first part of each deal is what is being offered to me.

DDC - is diamond die cut to be clear. ;)

1) Strasburg DDC, Felix Hernandez Black DDC, Mark Reynolds Black DDC for Strasburg Black DDC

(I can also trade the Stras black straight up for a Pujols black)

2) Delmon Young Diamond Embedded 1/1, Hank Aaron Black DDC for Toronto Blue Jays Diamond Embedded 1/1


3) I would like to start this one by asking why are so many people interested in the Justin Verlander DDC? I realize he will win the CY and has a shot at MVP but I am getting all kinds of trade offers for this card. And it is just the regular, not a black.

[B]But here are a few different offers all for a Verlander DDC.[/B]

1) Neftali Feliz DDC, Josh Johnson DDC + about 20 other cards that include (3) 1975's and a few other older 70's but nothing to mention by name.

2) David Price DDC, Alex Rios DDC + Jim Landis 1959

3) Hellickson DDC straight up.


I wish there was a way to send comments back so you could let them at least know the offer is close if necessary. Though I assume offers go out to all people that have the card if multiple are available?


Thanks in advance for the help!

i would jump on #2 for sure.

I'd do number 2 as well, I'm not sure about the first one though

Keep the Strasburg Black DDC.

Absolutely take #2

Hellickson for Verlander is the fairest of those but that's really personal preference.

I traded my verlander DDC for a hudson ddc back in like may, because Daniel hudson was one of my favorite players... wish I wouldve kept it :D

Do option #2

people make those offers b/c he wants verlander and could care less about the other crap cards and hoping u take offer b/c its so many cards with some DDC works for both sides

No to 1

Yes to 2 in a heartbeat!

Yes to 3rd option for 3