Blowout Cards Forums - View Single Post

TSonn · 08-08-2025, 12:18 PM

Each "GOAT" has their own thing:

Brady has 7 rings. Might not ever be beaten.
Montana was 4-0 in SBs.
Mahomes has 3 rings and a 2-peat but he's going to need something else that Brady and Montana didn't do. He's easily got the best highlight reel of this group and arguably changed the way the QB position is played (like Curry in the NBA) but I think he needs some stat that is easy to compare against Brady and Montana. Maybe double-digit straight AFCC appearances in a loaded AFC?

IMO another SB win puts him over Montana because getting to 6 SBs and winning 4 is better than getting to 4, but I know that's a tough sell to casuals who prefer first round exists over championship losses.

08-08-2025, 12:18 PM	#40937
TSonn Member Join Date: Aug 2019 Location: Michigan Posts: 5,971 TSonnMI	Each "GOAT" has their own thing: Brady has 7 rings. Might not ever be beaten. Montana was 4-0 in SBs. Mahomes has 3 rings and a 2-peat but he's going to need something else that Brady and Montana didn't do. He's easily got the best highlight reel of this group and arguably changed the way the QB position is played (like Curry in the NBA) but I think he needs some stat that is easy to compare against Brady and Montana. Maybe double-digit straight AFCC appearances in a loaded AFC? IMO another SB win puts him over Montana because getting to 6 SBs and winning 4 is better than getting to 4, but I know that's a tough sell to casuals who prefer first round exists over championship losses. Last edited by TSonn; 08-08-2025 at 12:37 PM.