Based on the inclusion of Bowman and Pro Debut, it looks like you are taking rookie card to just mean first base card. Is there a reason you have the Draft Gimenez instead of the Bowman below that was released earlier? I'm assuming it is just an oversight which is bound to happy across thousands of cards. On the base vs. insert, it's clear in cases where there is an insert in the same release as the first base, you choose the base. What do you do in a case like Bobby Witt Jr.? His first card was an insert in 2019 Best and his first base came in 2020 Bowman.
Sent from my Pixel 7 Pro using Tapatalk