2022 Hall of Fame Ballot

[JoshMN]

Originally Posted by JRX

Honest question, why is Mattingly not a hof now? More hits than Rolen, more gold gloves at his position, has an mvp. We're really basing everything on War positional adjustments?

The GGs were a joke (like Jeter's) and he was just an average hitter for half of a 14 year career (very short career by HOF standards).

Rolen was an elite defender. Mattingly was not an elite defender, but was a Yankee.

Mattingly had the talent to be a HOF, but injuries probably kept that from happening.