How to resolve this situation?

AllenWilliams87 · 11-18-2013, 01:31 PM

So a member and I did a blind trade about two weeks ago for base cards. He sent me 180 Tigers base cards (many dups, most from Bowman paper/Chrome) and asked for rookies in returned. I sent about 110 rookies only from Topps, Bowman, etc. His lot arrived about a week after we agreed, mine apparently has never arrived. I'm not smart and didn't have DC on it.

Naturally, he was upset. I took full responsibility and I kept telling him to send PP and I'll refund shipping and return the lot he sent me. Instead of sending me PP, he just wanted to call me a scammer and how I did this on purpose. FINALLY he sent me his PP information and I refunded him the exact cost to ship it and late last week, when the PP information was sent, did a return on the cards.

Now, he is asking for $40 for the lot or he will leave negative feedback. Did I do something wrong? He claimed the lot never arrived (Maybe he is scamming me? Doubt it but if he can accuse me, I can accuse him). I refunded the shipping he paid and am returning the cards. What else am I suppose to do? $40 for 180 base cards is a travesty and I could use help from the members here.

I know I should have used DC, I don't print labels for the most part and didn't think it was needed to spend $1 on a base card trade. Clearly I should have used a DC looking back, but I think I'm handling this as best as I can? If not, please help, thank you.

11-18-2013, 01:31 PM	#1
AllenWilliams87 Banned Join Date: Sep 2013 Posts: 852	How to resolve this situation? So a member and I did a blind trade about two weeks ago for base cards. He sent me 180 Tigers base cards (many dups, most from Bowman paper/Chrome) and asked for rookies in returned. I sent about 110 rookies only from Topps, Bowman, etc. His lot arrived about a week after we agreed, mine apparently has never arrived. I'm not smart and didn't have DC on it. Naturally, he was upset. I took full responsibility and I kept telling him to send PP and I'll refund shipping and return the lot he sent me. Instead of sending me PP, he just wanted to call me a scammer and how I did this on purpose. FINALLY he sent me his PP information and I refunded him the exact cost to ship it and late last week, when the PP information was sent, did a return on the cards. Now, he is asking for $40 for the lot or he will leave negative feedback. Did I do something wrong? He claimed the lot never arrived (Maybe he is scamming me? Doubt it but if he can accuse me, I can accuse him). I refunded the shipping he paid and am returning the cards. What else am I suppose to do? $40 for 180 base cards is a travesty and I could use help from the members here. I know I should have used DC, I don't print labels for the most part and didn't think it was needed to spend $1 on a base card trade. Clearly I should have used a DC looking back, but I think I'm handling this as best as I can? If not, please help, thank you. Last edited by AllenWilliams87; 11-18-2013 at 01:35 PM.