High End Peyton Manning future

devo · 10-09-2015, 09:45 PM

How do you guys think Peyton Manning's high end card values will do as time goes on, assuming he does not win another Super Bowl? Will they stay in the same range they're in now? Increase? Decrease? If you think they'll stay the same in the near future, how long do you think it will take for them to change in value? Will they be higher or lower than Brady's high end stuff?

Again, I'm not talking about his standard base cards, low/mid end autos or things of that nature, but rather his true high end cards, such as rookies, Exquisite, Ultimate Collection, etc... I've had a few discussions about this recently with some buddies who think he's not as safe of an investment as Brady or Rodgers because he's played for 2 teams. Their argument is that if he had played for the Colts his entire career then his card values would be better off in the future. Interested to hear some more thoughts on this...

10-09-2015, 09:45 PM	#1
devo Member Join Date: Sep 2015 Location: California Posts: 1,585	High End Peyton Manning future How do you guys think Peyton Manning's high end card values will do as time goes on, assuming he does not win another Super Bowl? Will they stay in the same range they're in now? Increase? Decrease? If you think they'll stay the same in the near future, how long do you think it will take for them to change in value? Will they be higher or lower than Brady's high end stuff? Again, I'm not talking about his standard base cards, low/mid end autos or things of that nature, but rather his true high end cards, such as rookies, Exquisite, Ultimate Collection, etc... I've had a few discussions about this recently with some buddies who think he's not as safe of an investment as Brady or Rodgers because he's played for 2 teams. Their argument is that if he had played for the Colts his entire career then his card values would be better off in the future. Interested to hear some more thoughts on this...