Giancarlo Stanton deserves his own thread

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by MoreToppsPlease

I enjoy pointing out that people looking to profit aren’t in a hobby which confuses you.

No confusion here.

[ScooterD]

Originally Posted by MoreToppsPlease

I enjoy pointing out that people looking to profit aren’t in a hobby which confuses you.

He said that your post showed that you enjoy collecting - nothing about a hobby or profit.

Why did your reply bring the conversation around to your compulsive perception of this hobby/profit concept?

Take the compliment he gave and give your obsession a rest.

[jhssketchcards]

44 WAR
1500 hits
.257 AVG
5 ASG
1 MVP
3 100 RBI seasons

Anyone who thinks Stanton is a HOF is getting crack from Hunter Biden.

Glad he’s having a great postseason but not even close to a HOF career. Even with 500 HR


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[ScooterD]

Originally Posted by jhssketchcards

44 WAE
1500 hits
.257 AVG
5 ASG
1 MVP
3 100 RBI seasons

Anyone who thinks Stanton is a HOF is getting crack from Hunter Biden.

Glad he’s having a great postseason but not even close to a HOF career. Even with 500 HR


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

If he gets to 500 HRs and never gets popped of PEDs or any other funny business, he will get in. That’s his only chance tho

Name a non-PED player with 500 HRs who isn’t

[Archangel1775]

Originally Posted by rfgilles

Stanton will need 500 home runs to have any shot at the Hall and I don't think he gets there. He isn't going to average 29 homeruns a season over the next 4 years.

He has had an OBP under .300 the last 3 years and is injury prone.

He is far from a lock and a big postseason series doesn't change that.

Originally Posted by jhssketchcards

44 WAE
1500 hits
.257 AVG
5 ASG
1 MVP
3 100 RBI seasons

Anyone who thinks Stanton is a HOF is getting crack from Hunter Biden.

Glad he’s having a great postseason but not even close to a HOF career. Even with 500 HR


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Something was lost in translation:

Stanton just completed his age 34 season
His current contract runs through the 2027 season
He has a Club Option for the 2028 season
He is an UFA for 2029 (He would likely retire)

2025-Age 35
2026-Age 36
2027-Age 37
2028-Age 38 (Club Option)

He needs 71 Home Runs over 3 seasons (End of current contract)

He just needs to average 24 Home Runs per season for the next 3.

Definitely doable

Once again, EVERY 500 Home Run Club member is in the Hall of Fame that isn't tied to steroids or named Pujols & Cabrera who aren't in only because they recently retired.

Of course with his injury history he could flail out and not reach 500 and any chance becomes zero.


So no, not on crack, just seeing it for what it is.

[jhssketchcards]

Originally Posted by Archangel1775

Something was lost in translation:

Stanton just completed his age 34 season
His current contract runs through the 2027 season
He has a Club Option for the 2028 season
He is an UFA for 2029 (He would likely retire)

2025-Age 35
2026-Age 36
2027-Age 37
2028-Age 38 (Club Option)

He needs 71 Home Runs over 3 seasons (End of current contract)

He just needs to average 24 Home Runs per season for the next 3.

Definitely doable

Once again, EVERY 500 Home Run Club member is in the Hall of Fame that isn't tied to steroids or named Pujols & Cabrera who aren't in only because they recently retired.

Of course with his injury history he could flail out and not reach 500 and any chance becomes zero.


So no, not on crack, just seeing it for what it is.

It’s ridiculous that we can zoom in on one HOF stat and determine a guys HOF worthiness while so many other players who contributed all across the game aren’t in.

The HOF is a joke now anyways, so I’m sure Stanton would get in with 500 HR, not because he IS a HOF player, but rather it’s a code or rule that you can be mediocre on all other levels but as long as you do one thing well, you’re in.

Fred McGriff and Carlos Delgado should be in over Stanton. Better overall hitters for sure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by jhssketchcards

It’s ridiculous that we can zoom in on one HOF stat and determine a guys HOF worthiness while so many other players who contributed all across the game aren’t in.

The HOF is a joke now anyways, so I’m sure Stanton would get in with 500 HR, not because he IS a HOF player, but rather it’s a code or rule that you can be mediocre on all other levels but as long as you do one thing well, you’re in.

Fred McGriff and Carlos Delgado should be in over Stanton. Better overall hitters for sure.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I have some good news for you: McGriff IS in the Hall of Fame! Woot!

I understand the heart of what you’re saying, but also… hitting 500 HRs is hard! Stanton would be only the 29th player in MLB history to get to that mark, if he actually makes it there.

[Sportnut08]

Some of my favorites in my collection:

















Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

^^^ Holy poop, man! Amazing stuff! ^^^

[MoreToppsPlease]

Originally Posted by ScooterD

He said that your post showed that you enjoy collecting - nothing about a hobby or profit.

Why did your reply bring the conversation around to your compulsive perception of this hobby/profit concept?

Take the compliment he gave and give your obsession a rest.

Why are you so triggered? This has nothing to do with you. Just remember hobbies don’t include trying to profit.

[ScooterD]

Originally Posted by MoreToppsPlease

Why are you so triggered? This has nothing to do with you. Just remember hobbies don’t include trying to profit.

Not triggered at all - just don’t mind sharing that your OCD (or whatever causes your behavior) is annoying to me.

You have some great cards

[Giancarlo27]

Originally Posted by Sportnut08

Some of my favorites in my collection:

















Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Be a doll and sell me one of those reds, you don’t need 2

[Giancarlo27]

Originally Posted by MoreToppsPlease

Fun to watch!

Now I now who has all the other flagship supers. Here’s my only one




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Sportnut08]

Originally Posted by Giancarlo27

Be a doll and sell me one of those reds, you don’t need 2

Feel free to PM me an offer. I may consider, especially if it makes me a doll.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[rfgilles]

Great Stanton cards posted recently. Those supers are awesome.

[no10pin]

Originally Posted by MiamiMarlinsFan

I have some good news for you: McGriff IS in the Hall of Fame! Woot!

I understand the heart of what you’re saying, but also… hitting 500 HRs is hard! Stanton would be only the 29th player in MLB history to get to that mark, if he actually makes it there.

As mentioned above, Stanton goes in with 500 and no failed tests. It is odd to me that it's really just a round number thing though.

I know historically that as long as you aren't problematic in one of two ways, 3000 hits and 500 HRs gets you in. Carlos Delgado was one and done on the HOF ballot and doesn't seem to be getting traction with the committee, but only 33 players in history have hit more home runs than him.

I don't have a problem at all with Stanton going in with 500+, but baseball is very very obsessed with numbers than end in 00 and 000.

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by no10pin

As mentioned above, Stanton goes in with 500 and no failed tests. It is odd to me that it's really just a round number thing though.

I know historically that as long as you aren't problematic in one of two ways, 3000 hits and 500 HRs gets you in. Carlos Delgado was one and done on the HOF ballot and doesn't seem to be getting traction with the committee, but only 33 players in history have hit more home runs than him.

I don't have a problem at all with Stanton going in with 500+, but baseball is very very obsessed with numbers than end in 00 and 000.

I get it. I grew up a fan of Delgado too.

[davidantx]

good player, however nowhere in the same universe of the HOF.

[Stifle]

Originally Posted by no10pin

As mentioned above, Stanton goes in with 500 and no failed tests. It is odd to me that it's really just a round number thing though.

I know historically that as long as you aren't problematic in one of two ways, 3000 hits and 500 HRs gets you in. Carlos Delgado was one and done on the HOF ballot and doesn't seem to be getting traction with the committee, but only 33 players in history have hit more home runs than him.

I don't have a problem at all with Stanton going in with 500+, but baseball is very very obsessed with numbers than end in 00 and 000.

He may not win another regular season MVP, but he doesn’t go MIA like so many other great players. His post season resume is exceptional. If he wins the WS MVP, a very nice caveat. Next season the team will have a great shot at the playoffs and he can climb up the playoff charts statistics as well.

[fulltritty]

Well deserved MVP. Hopefully, he keeps hitting those home runs in the World Series.

[ironfireman]

There are 270+ players in the HOF - Stanton is 51st currently in all time homeruns & 113th with OPS+ of 136 - He's a massive muscled giant who hit dingers! He's been awesome in the postseason and its a great story of a guy who just couldn't stay healthy.
A ring or 500 HRs and he's in.

[atk825]

Jim Rice got in the Hall based on his most feared status. Giancarlo will too.

[Handsome Wes]

Originally Posted by atk825

Jim Rice got in the Hall based on his most feared status. Giancarlo will too.

I wasn't around for the bulk of Jim Rice's career so I don't know how he was perceived *throughout* his career. Was he seen, even towards the end of his career, as a "feared" hitter? Or did he earn that moniker early on and it kinda stuck?

I ask because I don't know if - the theatrics of the last week notwithstanding - Giancarlo Stanton falls into the same category of being "feared". I think of him as an aged injury-prone hitter who, when healthy, has a ton of power and can hurt you if he gets into one, but otherwise brings average- or below average- production to the plate (and certainly on the basepaths).

(Not for nothing, I do remember Gary Sheffield being *feared* as a hitter - even towards the end - and that did little to advance his HOF candidacy. Of course, he had other circumstances that affected his vote total. But he was definitely feared. Maybe not just because of incredible bat speed, but also carried just a general "he hates the pitcher and could legitimately get violent if he wants to" vibe.)

I dunno. I'd love to see him (Stanton) get into the Hall of Fame. He has three more years on his contract and is 71 homers away from 500, which could be a tall order. I'd say it's 50/50.

[tjforce]

Originally Posted by ironfireman

There are 270+ players in the HOF - Stanton is 51st currently in all time homeruns & 113th with OPS+ of 136 - He's a massive muscled giant who hit dingers! He's been awesome in the postseason and its a great story of a guy who just couldn't stay healthy.
A ring or 500 HRs and he's in.

Originally Posted by atk825

Jim Rice got in the Hall based on his most feared status. Giancarlo will too.

He gets in if he gets to 500 and a WS with the Yankees. Easy.

Anyone who can't see this is too deep into nerd-dom to communicate with the general public.

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

Originally Posted by tjforce

He gets in if he gets to 500 and a WS with the Yankees. Easy.

Anyone who can't see this is too deep into nerd-dom to communicate with the general public.

Agreed.

Over the last three seasons, he’s been just as injury prone as ever, and still hit 82 HRs over that span. Asking for 71 more over the next 4-5 season isn’t much from him.