All I want to do is talk about COMC

[mc1]

Originally Posted by mjohnatgt

That's because they're ID'ing off of scans only, AFAIK. I think most of their ID team is in Dallas.

Man, this is getting ridiculous. Im even seeing a couple mislabeled graded cards! The PSA/BGS labels are actually correct and these guys still couldnt label the card correctly. Its getting bad, maybe they need to hire other people to ID.

[boxbuster7]

Originally Posted by DynaEtch

My bad I missed the discussion upthread. Yea $2.99 is good but don’t know why it’s still that expensive? Aren’t ESEs like a buck or so. They could have made these $1.99 and a $3 difference between that and bubble mailer would’ve been more noticeable.

cause they're a business - but ya $2.99 is steep for a single card

[fungi2510]

Holy moly. Shipping is back and on point. I shipped the cheapest option on 8/9 for an order of around 125 cards. It was scheduled to be shipped by 9/14. It shipped today. A week and a half? What? Has it ever been that fast? I am really not sure what to do with all of that. I cannot keep up getting my last orders listed on eBay by the time the next one is here. Too bad I am cleared out more than I should be. I would ship a ton home with these shipping times.

[Dredd84]

I’m sure this has been asked many times, so my apologies, but what’s the typical turnaround time for PSA submissions at the 45 day level?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[checkoutmydeals]

A week and a half? What? Has it ever been that fast?

In the old days, Standard packing was done in a week or so, and the cards would be in hand 1 to 2 weeks after placing the shipment.

I used to buy Magic the Gathering cards from COMC if I needed a card for a deck to be played in an event 2 weeks out. When combined with the relatively low processing fees of 25 cents or so, it was nearly as effective to park cards at COMC as it was to put them into a trade binder.

[boxbuster7]

Originally Posted by Dredd84

I’m sure this has been asked many times, so my apologies, but what’s the typical turnaround time for PSA submissions at the 45 day level?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

it's kinda all over the place - some pop sooner, some take longer - wouldn't be worried unless it was 60+

and it is business days I believe not 45 days

[fungi2510]

Originally Posted by checkoutmydeals

A week and a half? What? Has it ever been that fast?

In the old days, Standard packing was done in a week or so, and the cards would be in hand 1 to 2 weeks after placing the shipment.

I used to buy Magic the Gathering cards from COMC if I needed a card for a deck to be played in an event 2 weeks out. When combined with the relatively low processing fees of 25 cents or so, it was nearly as effective to park cards at COMC as it was to put them into a trade binder.

It was kinda rhetorical, but if they are close to that pace that you mentioned it is basically as good as it is going to get.

[Dredd84]

Originally Posted by boxbuster7

it's kinda all over the place - some pop sooner, some take longer - wouldn't be worried unless it was 60+

and it is business days I believe not 45 days

Thank you for the info! I really appreciate it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[boxbuster7]

anytime!

[NYJNYYFan]

I've noticed a continued trend were over 2/3 of my cards sell within the first few days of posting, especially when accepting offers.

I'm assuming people search their PC players or team by "most recent" and just refresh the site a few times a week.

I also rarely sell anything that remains, which can admittedly also be due to it being a less popular card as well. I've gotten better at figuring out what's worth sending in after a couple subs.

[duwal]

Originally Posted by Dredd84

I’m sure this has been asked many times, so my apologies, but what’s the typical turnaround time for PSA submissions at the 45 day level?

I have a Jokic Prizm RC on COMC that I requested grading submission on 6/8, it was graded and showed up in my inventory on 7/22

[JustinVerlander07]

Originally Posted by NYJNYYFan

I've noticed a continued trend were over 2/3 of my cards sell within the first few days of posting, especially when accepting offers.

I'm assuming people search their PC players or team by "most recent" and just refresh the site a few times a week.

I also rarely sell anything that remains, which can admittedly also be due to it being a less popular card as well. I've gotten better at figuring out what's worth sending in after a couple subs.

I personally search my main PCs at least once a day.

[Rabs]

Originally Posted by NYJNYYFan

I'm assuming people search their PC players or team by "most recent" and just refresh the site a few times a week.

I 100% do this as a buyer.

[Bulldog55D]

Originally Posted by NYJNYYFan

I've noticed a continued trend were over 2/3 of my cards sell within the first few days of posting, especially when accepting offers.

I'm assuming people search their PC players or team by "most recent" and just refresh the site a few times a week.

I also rarely sell anything that remains, which can admittedly also be due to it being a less popular card as well. I've gotten better at figuring out what's worth sending in after a couple subs.

Check my set needs every morning.

[Tiger23]

Some good news on the shipping front. I requested economy shipping of about 50 cards on 8/10. The estimated ship date was 9/9 with around 300,000 cards in front of mine. It ended up shipping 8/23.

[actionbryan]

Originally Posted by NYJNYYFan

I've noticed a continued trend were over 2/3 of my cards sell within the first few days of posting, especially when accepting offers.

I'm assuming people search their PC players or team by "most recent" and just refresh the site a few times a week.

I also rarely sell anything that remains, which can admittedly also be due to it being a less popular card as well. I've gotten better at figuring out what's worth sending in after a couple subs.

2/3 of your cards sell within a few days? And you rarely sell anything that remains?

[jerryw]

Originally Posted by actionbryan

2/3 of your cards sell within a few days? And you rarely sell anything that remains?

Mine as well….i let them all get uploaded and contact a couple big port buyers I use and usually sells pretty instantly…I use comc to clear my shelves at home of crap I don’t want and don’t have the patience to nickel and dime them. Take my % and move on lol

[NYJNYYFan]

Originally Posted by actionbryan

2/3 of your cards sell within a few days? And you rarely sell anything that remains?

It's a relatively small sample size, but here is the data I pulled.

Sub 1 - 160 Cards - April '23
April/May 85 Sales
June-August 17 Sales

Sub 2 - 33 Cards - Sep '23
Sep/Oct - 25 Sales
Nov-June '24 19 Sales

Sub 3 -47 Cards - Aug '24
Aug - 40 sales

My first sub was more of an experiment to see what sells on the site, and I sent a lot. Now the last 2 subs I've been more selective.

[NYJNYYFan]

Originally Posted by jerryw

Mine as well….i let them all get uploaded and contact a couple big port buyers I use and usually sells pretty instantly…I use comc to clear my shelves at home of crap I don’t want and don’t have the patience to nickel and dime them. Take my % and move on lol

I'm in a similar boat. I have a 5 row box that I try to go through once during football season and once during baseball. I price them to sell, excluding some higher value cards that I field offers on or sell through COMC auctions. If I don't get what I want I just have them shipped back home after a couple months.

[boxbuster7]

saw this condition note on a modern card and surprised comc is letting the seller still post it for sale

Condition Notes: evidence of trimming on top edge

[rentz]

did comc switch to live auctions ? i had some things i was going to send to auction and let it fly and only choices now are live auctions

[LSUNatChamps]

I have two cards that I noticed were listed "Not for Sale" even though I had previously listed them for sale. When I went to price them, I receive the error "There is a pending sale." Does anyone have experience with this issue? Do I need to contact COMC?

[NYJNYYFan]

Originally Posted by rentz

did comc switch to live auctions ? i had some things i was going to send to auction and let it fly and only choices now are live auctions

I recently did a regular 7 day auction on 2 cards. Maybe they have a backlog they need to run through first and will open that option back.

[boxbuster7]

Originally Posted by LSUNatChamps

I have two cards that I noticed were listed "Not for Sale" even though I had previously listed them for sale. When I went to price them, I receive the error "There is a pending sale." Does anyone have experience with this issue? Do I need to contact COMC?

if it has been more than a week or two you do need to email them to unlock it

[rentz]

Originally Posted by NYJNYYFan

I recently did a regular 7 day auction on 2 cards. Maybe they have a backlog they need to run through first and will open that option back.

yeah its just odd ive used auction before with 7days.
i'm going to try out a live auction and brace for a low final price.