BUYER BEWARE: Trimmed PSA-10 2000 Stadium Club Derek Jeter Co-Signers on Ebay

[corndog]

This auction for a PSA-10 2000 Stadium Club Co-Signers dual autograph card of Derek Jeter and Rey Ordonez was just recently listed on Ebay by seller markbrunell here: https://www.ebay.com/itm/2000-Stadiu...MAAOSwj8VcXNJ~

Worthpoint has two prior sales, one as raw back in July of 2013 here: https://www.worthpoint.com/worthoped...-co4-461132451
and one month later as a PSA-9 here: https://www.worthpoint.com/worthoped...2000-465010501

The card is not serial numbered but the two signatures are a match.

I don't need to use circles or anything, you can clearly see the two bad corners at the top on the raw card here:


A month later the card had been graded by PSA and given a 9 here:


And now the same card is being sold as a PSA-10 here:


Don't know anything about the seller, just pointing out yet another trimmed card graded by PSA.

[SaveMeTheGum]

Look at the seller...

[3124508 on COMC]

Look at this seller:




All trimmed cards lead to PWCC.

[corndog]

Originally Posted by 3124508 on COMC

Look at this seller:




All trimmed cards lead to PWCC.

When was that sale date? Maybe brunell can get a refund from PWCC since they sold the 10...

[3124508 on COMC]

Originally Posted by corndog

When was that sale date? Maybe brunell can get a refund from PWCC since they sold the 10...

January 2019. Item still shows on Ebay in completed listings.

[awz50]

Jesus pwcc really going down the poop hole

[KhalDrogo]

Will PWCC investigate who consigned that card?

[superdan49]

A couple of things I noticed here:

1) It has a new serial number with an older style flip (i.e., not a Lighthouse holder). That means the card was submitted to PSA by a big submitter.

2) It was once sold (or appears to be sold) as a PSA 9 by PSA.Gems, as seen in the description from corndog's second Worthpoint link. That is a Kevin Burge account, one of the more notorious criminals active in the industry.

[discostu]

Originally Posted by superdan49

A couple of things I noticed here:

1) It has a new serial number with an older style flip (i.e., not a Lighthouse holder). That means the card was submitted to PSA by a big submitter.

2) It was once sold (or appears to be sold) as a PSA 9 by PSA.Gems, as seen in the description from corndog's second Worthpoint link. That is a Kevin Burge account, one of the more notorious criminals active in the industry.

For the newer members, or members who don't know the name "Kevin Burge" - he was really in on the ground floor of the patch faking, scam game...with a colorful and shady history going back 10+ years.

[corndog]

Unbelievable sequence of events...

PWCC owes markbrunell a refund.

[superdan49]

Originally Posted by corndog

Unbelievable sequence of events...

PWCC owes markbrunell a refund.

Yup. Then PSA will be paying out PWCC to hopefully de-certify this card. Slabbing or selling altered cards might start getting expensive for the hobby superpowers.

[vwnut13]

Originally Posted by superdan49

Yup. Then PSA will be paying out PWCC to hopefully de-certify this card. Slabbing or selling altered cards might start getting expensive for the hobby superpowers.

What's the difference in value between a PSA 10 and an altered card?

PSA is going to have to raise grading fees to cover all these payouts.

[KhalDrogo]

Has someone reached out yet?

[HeritageKing]

If PSA can't detect a trimmed card here, why trust them with anything else?

[mjwoop]

The implication here is that this card may have been trimmed on two separate occasions, right?

PSA is taking a lot of serious credibility shots around here recently. If nothing else, I'm hopeful that it causes some (or at least one) of the resident PSA cheerleaders to put their pom-poms down for a bit.