NFL 100: Quarterbacks

[oplum29]

here are my predictions on the top 10:

Montana
Brady
Unitas
Elway
Brees
Manning
Otto Graham
Marino
Baugh
Tarkenton

Steve Young just misses the cut

anybody else? predictions? list comes out at 7pm cst

[Bassplayah101]

Brady

Everyone else



Sent from my SM-G975U using Tapatalk

[asujbl]

Why did Graham need a first name?

[Siberian13]

Originally Posted by asujbl

Why did Graham need a first name?

You ninja editing sob

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by Siberian13

You ninja editing sob

Not my first rodeo

[oplum29]

Originally Posted by asujbl

Why did Graham need a first name?

for those that would have no clue who he was..

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by oplum29

for those that would have no clue who he was..

Why would people not know who he is?

But they know Sammy Baugh?

[JustRachel]

Originally Posted by oplum29

here are my predictions on the top 10:

Montana
Brady
Unitas
Elway
Brees
Manning
Otto Graham
Marino
Baugh
Tarkenton

Steve Young just misses the cut

anybody else? predictions? list comes out at 7pm cst

I like your list. I'd replace Baugh and Tarkenton with Rodgers and Favre though. I personally don't think Favre is top 10 but I'm guessing they will. Rodgers is a no-brainer imo.

[Ray27Ray52]

For all the drama, interceptions, only one SB win, yadda yadda yadda it's amazing people have clearly forgotten how good Brett Favre was in his prime. He was must see television every single Sunday. No one could sling it like him when he was on.

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by Ray27Ray52

For all the drama, interceptions, only one SB win, yadda yadda yadda it's amazing people have clearly forgotten how good Brett Favre was in his prime. He was must see television every single Sunday. No one could sling it like him when he was on.

This is very true

[oplum29]

Originally Posted by Ray27Ray52

For all the drama, interceptions, only one SB win, yadda yadda yadda it's amazing people have clearly forgotten how good Brett Favre was in his prime. He was must see television every single Sunday. No one could sling it like him when he was on.

i'm a Niners fan, believe me, i know all about Favre. Cost us three straight seasons in the playoffs.

that's what made that 1998 Wild Card game so special, finally beating him the way we did.

[oplum29]

Originally Posted by JustRachel

I like your list. I'd replace Baugh and Tarkenton with Rodgers and Favre though. I personally don't think Favre is top 10 but I'm guessing they will. Rodgers is a no-brainer imo.

my only thing is, you can't have a top 10 all-time list and just have a bunch of modern day qbs, because the game has changed so much.

it's hard to ignore what Tarkenton did in the 1970s with the Vikings. the dude left the league with just about every passing record and was also the leading rusher for qbs, which was later broken by guys like Cam Newton and Steve Young, and probably Lamar Jackson in two-three years. He was also barely 6' ft tall, that's crazy.

[Siberian13]

You can bump guys like Marino. You should have a ring to be on that list.

[asujbl]

The Top 10 is this. Don’t @ me (not in order)

Brady
Montana
Manning
Graham
Favre
Brees
Elway
Unitas
Marino
Starbauch

[Siberian13]

Originally Posted by asujbl

The Top 10 is this. Don’t @ me (not in order)

Brady
Montana
Manning
Graham
Favre
Brees
Elway
Unitas
Marino
Starbauch

Starbauch?

[mainelobster]

Agree with some others. No chance Favre should be left off this list...

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by Siberian13

Starbauch?

Because he’s a star

Get it?

[oplum29]

Originally Posted by mainelobster

Agree with some others. No chance Favre should be left off this list...

you were right!

i was wrong. The list should have had at least one Packer, and from the three, Favre was my top pick, but he's been forgotten since he retired, that was why i didn't put him. stupid of me

[majestik101]

Originally Posted by asujbl

The Top 10 is this. Don’t @ me (not in order)

Brady
Montana
Manning
Graham
Favre
Brees
Elway
Unitas
Marino
Starbauch

I'm not seeing Lamar Jackson or Patty Mahomes


Also, which Manning?

[JustRachel]

Johnny Unitas won 3 MVPs. He's gotta be somewhere on this list, no? I'd forgotten about him earlier.

[patchgenie]

brady
peyton manning
otto graham
johhny unitas
joe montana
drew brees
brett favre
dan marino
aaron rodgers
big ben

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by majestik101

I'm not seeing Lamar Jackson or Patty Mahomes


Also, which Manning?

Baker Manning

[roberth404]

I mean, NFL Network did a Top 100 list about ten years ago when Jerry Rice was #1, so I don't think the update list should be a surprise. Anyways here's the list from 2010:

100-Joe Namath - QB

99 - Michael Strahan - DE

98 - Lee Roy Selmon - DE

97 - Derrick Brooks - LB

96 - Mel Hein - C

95 - Larry Allen - OL

94 - Lenny Moore - RB

93 - Sam Huff - LB

92 - Michael Irvin - WR

91 - Fran Tarkenton - QB

90 - Kurt Warner - QB

89 - Ernie Nevers - FB

88 - Ed Reed - S

87 - Elroy Hirsch - WR

86 - Willie Davis - DE

85 - Marcus Allen - RB

84 - Joe Schmidt - LB

83 - Norm Van Brocklin - QB

82 - Ted Hendricks - LB

81 - Steve Young - QB

80 - Troy Aikman - QB

79 - Emlen Tunnell - DB

78 - Bruce Matthews - OL

77 - Tony Dorsett - RB

76 - Art Shell - OL

75 - Darrell Green - CB

74 - Marion Motley - FB

73 - Ozzie Newsome - TE

72 - Jonathan Ogden - OT

71 - Paul Warfield - WR

70 - Marshall Faulk - RB

69 - Bobby Bell - LB

68 - Mike Webster - C

67 - Kellen Winslow, Sr. - TE

66 - Willie Brown - CB

65 - Randy Moss - WR

64 - Herb Adderley - CB

63 - Jim Otto - C

62 - Randy White - DT

61 - LaDainian Tomlinson - RB

60 - Jack Ham - LB

59 - Mike Ditka - TE

58 - Steve Van Buren - RB

57 - Mike Singletary- LB

56 - Gene Upshaw - OL

55 - Earl Campbell- RB

54 - Forrest Gregg - OT

53 - Willie Lanier - LB

52 - Eric Dickerson - RB

51 - Bart Starr - QB

50 - Terry Bradshaw - QB

49 - Mike Haynes - CB

48 - Red Grange - RB

47 - Ray Nitschke - LB

46 - Roger Staubach - QB

45 - Tony Gonzalez - TE

44 - Mel Blount - CB

43 - Alan Page - DT

42 - John Mackey - TE

41 - Rod Woodson - CB

40 - O.J. Simpson - RB

39 - Gino Marchetti - DE

38 - Lance Alworth - WR

37 - Jim Thorpe - TB/E/FB

36 - Raymond Berry - WR

35 - Chuck Bednarik - C/LB

34 - Deion Sanders - CB

33 - Sid Luckman - QB

32 - Jim Parker - LT

31 - Bruce Smith - DE

30 - "Night Train" Lane - DB

29 - Jack Lambert - LB

28 - Emmitt Smith - RB

27 - Merlin Olsen - DT

26 - Bob Lilly - DT

25 - Dan Marino - QB

24 - John Hannah - G

23 - John Elway - QB

22 - Gale Sayers - RB

21 - Tom Brady - QB

20 - Brett Favre - QB

19 - Bronko Nagurski - FB

18 - Ray Lewis - LB

17 - Barry Sanders - RB

16 - Otto Graham - QB

15 - Deacon Jones - DE

14 - Sammy Baugh - QB/DB/P

13 - Joe Greene - DT

12 - Anthony Munoz - LT

11 - Ronnie Lott - S

10 - Dick Butkus - LB

9 - Don Hutson - WR

8 - Peyton Manning - QB

7 - Reggie White - DE

6 - Johnny Unitas - QB

5 - Walter Payton - RB

4 - Joe Montana - QB

3 - Lawrence Taylor - LB

2 - Jim Brown -RB

1 - Jerry Rice - WR

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by roberth404

I mean, NFL Network did a Top 100 list about ten years ago when Jerry Rice was #1, so I don't think the update list should be a surprise. Anyways here's the list from 2010:

100-Joe Namath - QB

99 - Michael Strahan - DE

98 - Lee Roy Selmon - DE

97 - Derrick Brooks - LB

96 - Mel Hein - C

95 - Larry Allen - OL

94 - Lenny Moore - RB

93 - Sam Huff - LB

92 - Michael Irvin - WR

91 - Fran Tarkenton - QB

90 - Kurt Warner - QB

89 - Ernie Nevers - FB

88 - Ed Reed - S

87 - Elroy Hirsch - WR

86 - Willie Davis - DE

85 - Marcus Allen - RB

84 - Joe Schmidt - LB

83 - Norm Van Brocklin - QB

82 - Ted Hendricks - LB

81 - Steve Young - QB

80 - Troy Aikman - QB

79 - Emlen Tunnell - DB

78 - Bruce Matthews - OL

77 - Tony Dorsett - RB

76 - Art Shell - OL

75 - Darrell Green - CB

74 - Marion Motley - FB

73 - Ozzie Newsome - TE

72 - Jonathan Ogden - OT

71 - Paul Warfield - WR

70 - Marshall Faulk - RB

69 - Bobby Bell - LB

68 - Mike Webster - C

67 - Kellen Winslow, Sr. - TE

66 - Willie Brown - CB

65 - Randy Moss - WR

64 - Herb Adderley - CB

63 - Jim Otto - C

62 - Randy White - DT

61 - LaDainian Tomlinson - RB

60 - Jack Ham - LB

59 - Mike Ditka - TE

58 - Steve Van Buren - RB

57 - Mike Singletary- LB

56 - Gene Upshaw - OL

55 - Earl Campbell- RB

54 - Forrest Gregg - OT

53 - Willie Lanier - LB

52 - Eric Dickerson - RB

51 - Bart Starr - QB

50 - Terry Bradshaw - QB

49 - Mike Haynes - CB

48 - Red Grange - RB

47 - Ray Nitschke - LB

46 - Roger Staubach - QB

45 - Tony Gonzalez - TE

44 - Mel Blount - CB

43 - Alan Page - DT

42 - John Mackey - TE

41 - Rod Woodson - CB

40 - O.J. Simpson - RB

39 - Gino Marchetti - DE

38 - Lance Alworth - WR

37 - Jim Thorpe - TB/E/FB

36 - Raymond Berry - WR

35 - Chuck Bednarik - C/LB

34 - Deion Sanders - CB

33 - Sid Luckman - QB

32 - Jim Parker - LT

31 - Bruce Smith - DE

30 - "Night Train" Lane - DB

29 - Jack Lambert - LB

28 - Emmitt Smith - RB

27 - Merlin Olsen - DT

26 - Bob Lilly - DT

25 - Dan Marino - QB

24 - John Hannah - G

23 - John Elway - QB

22 - Gale Sayers - RB

21 - Tom Brady - QB

20 - Brett Favre - QB

19 - Bronko Nagurski - FB

18 - Ray Lewis - LB

17 - Barry Sanders - RB

16 - Otto Graham - QB

15 - Deacon Jones - DE

14 - Sammy Baugh - QB/DB/P

13 - Joe Greene - DT

12 - Anthony Munoz - LT

11 - Ronnie Lott - S

10 - Dick Butkus - LB

9 - Don Hutson - WR

8 - Peyton Manning - QB

7 - Reggie White - DE

6 - Johnny Unitas - QB

5 - Walter Payton - RB

4 - Joe Montana - QB

3 - Lawrence Taylor - LB

2 - Jim Brown -RB

1 - Jerry Rice - WR

Ok...

[silverandblack]

Originally Posted by patchgenie

brady
peyton manning
otto graham
johhny unitas
joe montana
drew brees
brett favre
dan marino
aaron rodgers
big ben

Hahaha Big Ben isn’t anywhere close to being on this list.