Question about psa auto grades

[Biohazarddfl]

If a card is graded gem mint, but they gave it a 9 auto. Can you re-sub to get the auto grade removed and just have a psa 10 card?

If so, do they re-inspect the card? Or is it just a lock, assuming the case is in perfect shape and wasn't tampered with.

Thanks in advance!

Sent from my SM-S901U using Tapatalk

[mjohnatgt]

Yes, you can reholder it to just have it say PSA/DNA Authentic for the auto. It's automatic if the holder hasn't been tampered with.

[Biohazarddfl]

Originally Posted by mjohnatgt

Yes, you can reholder it to just have it say PSA/DNA Authentic for the auto. It's automatic if the holder hasn't been tampered with.

Thanks a ton!

Sent from my SM-S901U using Tapatalk

[trouts2]

Yes you can. You can even just omit the auto grade just to have a psa 10 gem.

[mjohnatgt]

Originally Posted by trouts2

Yes you can. You can even just omit the auto grade just to have a psa 10 gem.

Depends on why it was sent through dual grading. If it's pre-1998 or IP/TTM signed (not factory original), the PSA/DNA has to stay on it.

[dictoresno]

Originally Posted by mjohnatgt

Depends on why it was sent through dual grading. If it's pre-1998 or IP/TTM signed (not factory original), the PSA/DNA has to stay on it.

however the auto grade can still be swapped for authentic instead of a 9.

[rhineland]

Conversely, if a card is graded Authentic with a 10 auto, can you re-sub to get a numerical grade on the card without them having to re-grade the auto?

[mjohnatgt]

Originally Posted by rhineland

Conversely, if a card is graded Authentic with a 10 auto, can you re-sub to get a numerical grade on the card without them having to re-grade the auto?

Yes, you just have to fill out the form correctly.

[vacardsguy]

General question...for factory auto’s whats the benefit of a number graded auto vs Authentic at resale? Does a 8 or 9 auto sell for more than an A? Thanks in advance

[dictoresno]

Originally Posted by vacardsguy

General question...for factory auto’s whats the benefit of a number graded auto vs Authentic at resale? Does a 8 or 9 auto sell for more than an A? Thanks in advance

I think most people grading 1998+ factory autos don't bother even getting the auto graded as its not necessary. but, auto grade is a personal preference. I think it would depend on the circumstances.

[Stack]

If I have a couple of nice modern RC's that have gemmed but the auto came back an 8. (First time subbing auto so thought I had to)

Do you guys think that would deter a buyer since most only care about the card grade?

Or worth reholdering and removing the grade?

[RufussCkingston]

What are the cards worth? Must be pretty ugly auto's to get an 8

[Stack]

Originally Posted by RufussCkingston

What are the cards worth? Must be pretty ugly auto's to get an 8

I would probably put each card in the 800 range or so in Gem Mint? The auto's don't look bad at all. I think because some parts the sharpie is not pressed down as hard as the other parts so more faded looking?

I mean these are factory autos pulled from packs.

[Stack]

Honestly don't think either is bad enough for an 8 that I got.

[dictoresno]

Originally Posted by Stack

Honestly don't think either is bad enough for an 8 that I got.

pretty streaky, I guess how I could see that getting an 8.

[Stack]

Originally Posted by dictoresno

pretty streaky, I guess how I could see that getting an 8.

I guess that is the reasoning. My fault for doing that grading. Learned my lesson. Now is it worth reholdering or people not gonna care as much since card is gem.