What’s the difference between Stetson Bennett and Bryce Young?

[kyle1707]

Draft #1 and drafted #128

One QB won a little more
One QB is a little bigger
One QB has a little better arm
One QB is a little faster
One had a better completion %

The one would be Stetson Bennett

Young is 21/22 and Bennett is 25/26 years old

Will be interesting who has a better NFL career

I’m saying it is very close and very average.

They seem so similar yet so different in eyes of NFL

[Moneychrome20]

Lol funny

[asujbl]

I’ve seen some stupid posts in my years. This one is legit top 5

[NSGJT]

One is a top 1-5 caliber prospect the other is borderline 6th-7th round to UDFA, hope that clarifies it for you.

[jplarson]

[majestik101]

[kluke84]

2 Nattys and a public intox

[mc1]

Originally Posted by kyle1707

Young is 21/22 and Bennett is 25/26 years old

They seem so similar yet so different in eyes of NFL

So similar. One is almost as old as Lamar Jackson and Joe Burrow.

[marinocollector]

Let me tell you about a man named Chris Weinke…

[SDcardguy24]

I thought your Levis > Richardson takes were bad enough but then you go and post this

[88horsepower]

Originally Posted by marinocollector

Let me tell you about a man named Chris Weinke…

Bingo.

Heisman winner - check
National championship - check
Maturity and Leadership - check
Ideal QB Build - check

15 touchdowns and 26 interceptions for his NFL career

Just because you can check some boxes doesn't mean much.

[kyle1707]

Originally Posted by SDcardguy24

I thought your Levis > Richardson takes were bad enough but then you go and post this

Well it’s set in stone .. always fun to go back to these after year or 2 and read them

It’s not that I think Levis will be Josh Allen. I just think Richardson will be a bust …. I have never seen such a bad power 5 qb get drafted so high ..

Young will be better than Bennett. He will have many more opportunities ..But with his size he will never be close to elite

Not sure why those are such crazy takes ?

But I will stand by. Besides age. Bennett and young are very similar college players and I can’t believe young was drafted 1.

[Moneychrome20]

Originally Posted by kyle1707

Well it’s set in stone .. always fun to go back to these after year or 2 and read them

It’s not that I think Levis will be Josh Allen. I just think Richardson will be a bust …. I have never seen such a bad power 5 qb get drafted so high ..

Young will be better than Bennett. He will have many more opportunities ..But with his size he will never be close to elite

Not sure why those are such crazy takes ?

But I will stand by. Besides age. Bennett and young are very similar college players and I can’t believe young was drafted 1.

U would never make it as an nfl anything scout Gm or water boy your takes are horrible I guess drew Brees was never elite because he was 6’0

Just log off dude

[mc1]

Originally Posted by kyle1707

But I will stand by. Besides age. Bennett and young are very similar college players and I can’t believe young was drafted 1.

Players arent drafted for what theyve done and what theyve been.
Theyre drafted for what they might do and who they could become.

[JeremyNick]

I got another similarity.

Neither will amount to much in the NFL.

[kyle1707]

Originally Posted by Moneychrome20

U would never make it as an nfl anything scout Gm or water boy your takes are horrible I guess drew Brees was never elite because he was 6Â’0

Just log off dude

Come on Chrome $$$$$$

You really think a 5Â’9 187 pound qb who was surrounded by the best talent in college football 95 % percent of the games he played should be number 1?

For the second time I have no clue why that is a bad take. ?

Either lots of bama fans or people already investing which is cool

But to tell someone to sign off because I donÂ’t think top pick was a good pick

Mariotta
Winston
Wentz
Rosen
Baker
Kyler ? Could be on this list soon. ItÂ’s close imo
Tua will be soon . I fear his frame and health
Wilson
Mac ? Needs a bounce back ..
Trey. Can he stay healthy ? Make or break year imo
Fields I like. This is year 3 you have to show it passing
2022 class was all drafted later. Which most of these guys should of been 2-3-4 round picks
So just in last 8 years just massive percent of failed or qbÂ’s who should not of been drafted in top 10

So to say itÂ’s a bad take and get lost ?

Will see chrome $$$. Will see

[asujbl]

Originally Posted by kyle1707

Come on Chrome $$$$$$

You really think a 5Â’9 187 pound qb who was surrounded by the best talent in college football 95 % percent of the games he played should be number 1?

For the second time I have no clue why that is a bad take. ?

Either lots of bama fans or people already investing which is cool

But to tell someone to sign off because I donÂ’t think top pick was a good pick

Mariotta
Winston
Wentz
Rosen
Baker
Kyler ? Could be on this list soon. ItÂ’s close imo
Tua will be soon . I fear his frame and health
Wilson
Mac ? Needs a bounce back ..
Trey. Can he stay healthy ? Make or break year imo
Fields I like. This is year 3 you have to show it passing
2022 class was all drafted later. Which most of these guys should of been 2-3-4 round picks
So just in last 8 years just massive percent of failed or qbÂ’s who should not of been drafted in top 10

So to say itÂ’s a bad take and get lost ?

Will see chrome $$$. Will see

Drop the 4th or 5th round QB success rate

Thanks

[TheFrenzy]

Breathe it in boys.

This is the good stuff right here.

[Archangel1775]

Probably the same difference between every 1st round QB and those drafted afterwards

[imbluestreak23]

Light skin don't help

[mc1]

Originally Posted by imbluestreak23

Light skin don't help

So thats why Brady fell to the 6th round?

[BraveAtlanta]

There is one thing I will never do again (nor any UGA fan or coach) and that’s doubt Stetson Bennett. If you haven’t followed the program closely for a while, you may not know the whole story or understand what he went through. We don’t win back to back NCs without him. “He’s the greatest walk on ever” is just part of it.

[EBCollectibles]

Originally Posted by mc1

So similar. One is almost as old as Lamar Jackson and Joe Burrow.

Also so similar. How many Alabama QB's turn out to be franchise QB's? Recent ones Mac Jones isn't to good, Tua isn't to good and has a concussion seems like every few games.

[jhssketchcards]

College greatness and NFL star are not always the same thing. I remember several great college QBs who never translated to NFL star:

Tebow
Mariota
RGIII
Leinart
Crouch
Quinn
Mayfield
Murray
Bradford
V. Young

I’m not saying Bennett nor Young will be NFL busts, but percentages aren’t in the side of both of them becoming stars. What Bennett did at UGA is amazing, and a phenomenal story in all of NCAA history, but as amazing as he was in BTB seasons, he only finished top 10 Heisman 1 time.

Many NFL stars, and HOF even, didn’t win a Heisman so I don’t put alot of stock in that award.
Winning championships is a great measure of success in the NFL, but no one considers Jim Plunkett nor Eli Manning ATG great QBs (some may argue for Manning). Plunkett did win a Heisman, whereas Manning finished 3rd in voting).

The list below shows QBs with a combined 19 SBs wins between them, but none of them won the Heisman trophy:

Patrick Mahomes
Peyton Mamning
Dan Marino
John Elway
Ben Roethlisberger
Joe Montana
Tom Brady
Terry Bradshaw

A great example is Archie Griffin and Walter Payton.
Griffin finished 3 straight years as a Heisman:

5th place Sophomore yr
1st Junior yr
1st Senior yr

Walter Payton never made the top 10. Not once.
We all know Payton became an NFL icon while Griffin never amounted to much in the NFL.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[oldgoldy97]

I don’t think many people thought Eric Crouch would be a good pro.