BGS Question

[geebgoody]

I have a 2020 topps heritage pete alonso rookie auto. I sent it to beckett during covid and was disappointed it came in an 8.5. I tucked it away until recently and got looking it over. Becket got the card name wrong on the slab. They list it as a 2017 topps heritage minors real one auto. My question is does it having a beckett "error" make it worth any more or less?

[1800gambler]

Originally Posted by geebgoody

I have a 2020 topps heritage pete alonso rookie auto. I sent it to beckett during covid and was disappointed it came in an 8.5. I tucked it away until recently and got looking it over. Becket got the card name wrong on the slab. They list it as a 2017 topps heritage minors real one auto. My question is does it having a beckett "error" make it worth any more or less?

Definitely doesn’t increase the value, it decreases it since I’d have to go through the trouble of reslabbing it to fix it If I were to buy a mistake like that

[MiamiMarlinsFan]

That only decreases the value. Crack it, send it to PSA, and hope for a 9.

[HalfNipponese]

Originally Posted by geebgoody

I have a 2020 topps heritage pete alonso rookie auto. I sent it to beckett during covid and was disappointed it came in an 8.5. I tucked it away until recently and got looking it over. Becket got the card name wrong on the slab. They list it as a 2017 topps heritage minors real one auto. My question is does it having a beckett "error" make it worth any more or less?

If I saw it at a show, I'd expect to see it slightly discounted due to the error. Cracking and resubmitting to PSA or a label correction are my suggestions.

[geebgoody]

Thanks! Appreciate everyone's time!