Thinking of selling on fanatics

PrimeGrails · 03-10-2026, 07:50 PM

I have a card that I want to sell on fanatics but I’m not really sure how the whole thing works, looking for wisdom on shipping your cards to them. I assume you do the same thing as PSA with registered mail or something with insurance. The card I’m selling a similar copy just sold for 16 K at a PSA 6. I have a freshly graded PSA 8. Do they choose if you are in the premier auction or not? Shipping cards is the most stressful thing for me lol. It’s daunting to find myself in this position after not being in the card game for a long time.

KhalDrogo · 03-11-2026, 05:11 AM

Just find the closest large show and travel to it if you’re afraid to ship. They’re at all the big shows accepting submissions.

You choose Premier vs Weekly. Just has to meet the Premier minimum, which your card easily does.

sthoemke · 03-11-2026, 04:13 PM

They have a very small user base, but you could send it to ebay through them.

Selling it on COMC (send to ebay from there too) might be another option.

Or cosign it to an auction house (Goldin, HA, etc)

boxbuster7 · 03-11-2026, 05:19 PM

I wouldn't run it via auction - I just auctioned a card and was told $1,000 or so and it sold for $750.

Theres just too many bangers there. I would sell it buy it now unless you're fine getting less than market value.

Blazed · 03-11-2026, 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimeGrails

I have a card that I want to sell on fanatics but I’m not really sure how the whole thing works, looking for wisdom on shipping your cards to them. I assume you do the same thing as PSA with registered mail or something with insurance. The card I’m selling a similar copy just sold for 16 K at a PSA 6. I have a freshly graded PSA 8. Do they choose if you are in the premier auction or not? Shipping cards is the most stressful thing for me lol. It’s daunting to find myself in this position after not being in the card game for a long time.

The Favre PMG red?

If so I saw that and have a copy as well

I was waiting to see if it gets paid for

PrimeGrails · 03-19-2026, 11:43 AM

No going back now boys! I’m in the premier auction in April. Hopefully it goes good. Either way it’s all good.

finfangfan · 03-19-2026, 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimeGrails

No going back now boys! I’m in the premier auction in April. Hopefully it goes good. Either way it’s all good.

Good luck!

coltsfan23 · 03-19-2026, 12:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Blazed

The Favre PMG red?

If so I saw that and have a copy as well

I was waiting to see if it gets paid for

Seller confirmed it was paid for, he couldn't believe it sold that high either

PrimeGrails · 03-19-2026, 12:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coltsfan23

Seller confirmed it was paid for, he couldn't believe it sold that high either

I was watching it live and was blown away, I wonder why?

boxbuster7 · 03-19-2026, 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by coltsfan23

Seller confirmed it was paid for, he couldn't believe it sold that high either

how much did it go for?

PrimeGrails · 03-19-2026, 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxbuster7

how much did it go for?

16.2k

boxbuster7 · 03-19-2026, 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PrimeGrails

16.2k

congrats! when did you get it originally?

PrimeGrails · 03-19-2026, 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by boxbuster7

congrats! when did you get it originally?

It wasn’t mine, I have a PSA 8 in the April premiere auction. New cert as well

03-10-2026, 07:50 PM	#1
PrimeGrails Member Join Date: Jan 2026 Posts: 37	Thinking of selling on fanatics I have a card that I want to sell on fanatics but I’m not really sure how the whole thing works, looking for wisdom on shipping your cards to them. I assume you do the same thing as PSA with registered mail or something with insurance. The card I’m selling a similar copy just sold for 16 K at a PSA 6. I have a freshly graded PSA 8. Do they choose if you are in the premier auction or not? Shipping cards is the most stressful thing for me lol. It’s daunting to find myself in this position after not being in the card game for a long time.

03-11-2026, 05:11 AM	#2
KhalDrogo Member Join Date: Aug 2017 Posts: 41,524	Just find the closest large show and travel to it if you’re afraid to ship. They’re at all the big shows accepting submissions. You choose Premier vs Weekly. Just has to meet the Premier minimum, which your card easily does. __________________ I love PSA!

03-11-2026, 04:13 PM	#3
sthoemke Member Join Date: Jul 2012 Location: Parts Unknown Posts: 6,542 sthoemke sthoemke	They have a very small user base, but you could send it to ebay through them. Selling it on COMC (send to ebay from there too) might be another option. Or cosign it to an auction house (Goldin, HA, etc) __________________ [signature goes here]

03-11-2026, 05:19 PM	#4
boxbuster7 Member Join Date: Aug 2016 Posts: 13,446 boxbuster777	I wouldn't run it via auction - I just auctioned a card and was told $1,000 or so and it sold for $750. Theres just too many bangers there. I would sell it buy it now unless you're fine getting less than market value. __________________ Psa 9 > psa 10

03-19-2026, 11:43 AM	#6
PrimeGrails Member Join Date: Jan 2026 Posts: 37	No going back now boys! I’m in the premier auction in April. Hopefully it goes good. Either way it’s all good.