I'd take Garrard over Alex Smith all day.

mcgahee21nfl · 03-19-2012, 10:00 AM

Garrard is a proven winner. He's had some pretty good seasons (none really bad) with the Jaguars, who have never had a really good team that he should've went further with. The guy can flat out manage the game like a true QB should.

Alex on the other hand, was just a benefit of Jim Harbaugh's coaching. The guy sucked when he should've been great all years prior to last.

$8m for Alex, versus like $3mil for Garrard? ---- LOL if Miami messes this one up too.

MASNAR · 03-19-2012, 10:01 AM

Alex helped 49ers get to NFC champ game 2011. Gerrard didn't play in 2011 at all did he?

JamiMadrox · 03-19-2012, 10:11 AM

Id take Smith over Garrard and I wouldnt even have to consider it.

DetectiveChrome · 03-19-2012, 10:11 AM

I don't want either.

When I think of the Niners and their success, Smith is not the first or second aspect of that comes to mind.

Miami doesn't have a the #1 defense, a kicker who can win games (Carpenter had a terrible season) and the off. coaching Niners have, so I'd be shocked if Smith had a good season out the gate in a Fins uni.

Boo · 03-19-2012, 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mcgahee21nfl

Garrard is a proven winner. He's had some pretty good seasons (none really bad) with the Jaguars, who have never had a really good team that he should've went further with. The guy can flat out manage the game like a true QB should.

Alex on the other hand, was just a benefit of Jim Harbaugh's coaching. The guy sucked when he should've been great all years prior to last.

$8m for Alex, versus like $3mil for Garrard? ---- LOL if Miami messes this one up too.

Give me Alex Smith. BTW if Smith benfited from Harbaugh's coaching, did Aaron Rodgers benefit from Philin's coaching the past 4 years? Packers offense >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>49ers offense

DetectiveChrome · 03-19-2012, 10:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Boo

Give me Alex Smith. BTW if Smith benfited from Harbaugh's coaching, did Aaron Rodgers benefit from Philin's coaching the past 4 years? Packers offense >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>49ers offense

I forgot about that...let's hope Philbin at the head position works out.

03-19-2012, 10:11 AM	#4
DetectiveChrome Member Join Date: May 2010 Location: Toronto Posts: 4,492 throwback_deluxe1 MegacityManiac	I don't want either. When I think of the Niners and their success, Smith is not the first or second aspect of that comes to mind. Miami doesn't have a the #1 defense, a kicker who can win games (Carpenter had a terrible season) and the off. coaching Niners have, so I'd be shocked if Smith had a good season out the gate in a Fins uni. __________________ http://s1099.photobucket.com/albums/g398/smarra/ For shipping purposes: I'm from Toronto (Canada)

03-19-2012, 10:00 AM	#1
mcgahee21nfl Inactive Account Join Date: Mar 2009 Posts: 6,555	I'd take Garrard over Alex Smith all day. Garrard is a proven winner. He's had some pretty good seasons (none really bad) with the Jaguars, who have never had a really good team that he should've went further with. The guy can flat out manage the game like a true QB should. Alex on the other hand, was just a benefit of Jim Harbaugh's coaching. The guy sucked when he should've been great all years prior to last. $8m for Alex, versus like $3mil for Garrard? ---- LOL if Miami messes this one up too.

03-19-2012, 10:01 AM	#2
MASNAR Member Join Date: Oct 2010 Location: Colorado Posts: 1,136	Alex helped 49ers get to NFC champ game 2011. Gerrard didn't play in 2011 at all did he?

03-19-2012, 10:11 AM	#3
JamiMadrox Banned Join Date: Feb 2011 Location: Oroville, CA Posts: 1,540	Id take Smith over Garrard and I wouldnt even have to consider it.