1998 Peyton Manning SP Authentic Replacement Card

[jareynolds]

Everyone

I had a chance to buy one of these cards in very nice condition. For those that don't know what these are:

"Due to the condition problems, there were a large number of the cards that were sent back to Upper Deck for replacement, but collectors soon found out that Upper Deck replaced their factory numbered cards with "hand-numbered" cards."

Do the hand numbered replaced cards hurt the value of the manning rookie card? Is there a noticeable difference in the market price vs the machine stamped version?

[coureymarshall]

Originally Posted by jareynolds

Do the hand numbered replaced cards hurt the value of the manning rookie card? Is there a noticeable difference in the market price vs the machine stamped version?

There is a slight difference in the "hand-numbered" SP Authentic rookie cards. The "hand-numbered" cards usually do not sell for as much as the "factory stamped" serial numbered cards.

In my personal opinion, it is still a great card for any collector!

[jareynolds]

Originally Posted by coureymarshall

There is a slight difference in the "hand-numbered" SP Authentic rookie cards. The "hand-numbered" cards usually do not sell for as much as the "factory stamped" serial numbered cards.

In my personal opinion, it is still a great card for any collector!

are we talking 5%? 10% 20% difference?

[MW Connection]

Originally Posted by jareynolds

are we talking 5%? 10% 20% difference?

it is rather small really like 10-15%.

[coureymarshall]

Originally Posted by MW Connection

it is rather small really like 10-15%.

I would agree with MW Connection