HOF Member Game-Used List

[GUCD231]

I wanted to post this list for any of the HOF Game-Used collectors like myself to serve as a running checklist for what's available now and in the future. I believe what's on the list now is accurate, but there may be someone I've missed or a old/recent addition I'm not aware of. I will update the list with any new revelations. Any insight, additions or objections are welcome.


Hank Aaron
Dick Allen
Roberto Alomar
Walter Alston
Sparky Anderson
Louis Aparicio
Luke Appling
Richie Ashburn
Earl Averill
Jeff Bagwell
Harold Baines
Frank Baker
Dave Bancroft
Ernie Banks
Johnny Bench
Carlos Beltran
Adrian Beltre
James "Cool Papa" Bell
Yogi Berra
Craig Biggio
Bert Blyleven
Wade Boggs
Jim Bottomley
Lou Boudreau
Roger Bresnahan
George Brett
Lou Brock
Jim Bunning
Roy Campanella
Rod Carew
Max Carey
Steve Carlton
Gary Carter
Orlando Cepeda
Frank Chance
Roberto Clemente
Ty Cobb
Mickey Cochrane
Eddie Collins
Earle Combs
Jocko Conlan
Bobby Cox
Sam Crawford
Joe Cronin
Kiki Cuyler
Andre Dawson
Leon Day - 2001 UD Gold Glove Leather Bound Glove (100 copies)
Dizzy Dean
Bill Dickey
Joe DiMaggio
Larry Doby
Bobby Doerr
Don Drysdale
Leo Durocher
Dennis Eckersley
Johnny Evers
Bob Feller
Rick Ferrell
Rollie Fingers
Carlton Fisk
Whitey Ford
Nellie Fox
Jimmy Foxx
Frank Frisch
Lou Gehrig
Charles Gehringer
Bob Gibson
Josh Gibson
Tom Glavine
Lefty Gomez
Goose Goslin
Rich Gossage
Hank Greenberg
Ken Griffey Jr.
Burleigh Grimes
Lefty Grove
Vladimir Guerrero
Tony Gywnn
Bucky Harris
Roy Halladay
Gabby Hartnett
Harry Heilmann
Todd Helton
Rickey Henderson
Bill Herman
Whitey Herzog
Gil Hodges
Trevor Hoffman
Harry Hooper
Roger Hornsby
Miller Huggins
Jim Hunter
Monte Irvin
Reggie Jackson
Fergie Jenkins
Derek Jeter
Randy Johnson
Walter Johnson - GU ball relic limited to 2011 Prime Cuts (4 cards) & 2012 NT (20 cards)
Chipper Jones
Andruw Jones
Addie Joss
Jim Kaat
Al Kaline
Willie Keeler
George Kell
George Kelly
Jeff Kent
Harmon Killebrew
Ralph Kiner
Chuck Klein
Sandy Koufax
Nap Lajoie
Barry Larkin
Tony LaRussa
Tom Lasorda
Tony Lazzeri
Bob Lemon
Frank Lindstrom
Ernie Lombardi
Al Lopez
Ted Lyons
Greg Maddux
Mickey Mantle
Heinie Manush
Juan Marichal
Pedro Martinez
Edgar Martinez
Eddie Mathews
Christy Mathewson
Joe Mauer
Willie Mays
Bill Mazeroski
Joe McCarthy
Willie McCovey
John McGraw
Fred McGriff
Joe Medwick
Marvin Miller
Minnie Minoso
Johnny Mize
Paul Molitor
Joe Morgan
Jack Morris
Eddie Murray
Stan Musial
Mike Mussina
Hal Newhouser
Phil Niekro
Tony Oliva
David Ortiz
Mel Ott
Satchel Paige
Jim Palmer
Dave Parker
Herb Pennock
Tony Perez
Gaylord Perry
Mike Piazza
Kirby Puckett
Tim Raines
Pee Wee Reese
Jim Rice
Sam Rice
Cal Ripken
Mariano Rivera
Phil Rizzuto
Robin Roberts
Brooks Robinson
Frank Robinson
Jackie Robinson
Ivan Rodriguez
Scott Rolen
Edd Roush
Babe Ruth
Nolan Ryan
C.C. Sabathia
Ryan Sandberg
Ron Santo
Mike Schmidt
Red Schoendienst
Tom Seaver
Joe Sewell
Al Simmons
Ted Simmons
George Sisler
Enos Slaughter
Ozzie Smith
Lee Smith
John Smoltz
Duke Snider
Billy Southworth
Warren Spahn
Tris Speaker
Willie Stargell
Casey Stengel
Bruce Sutter
Mule Suttles
Don Sutton
Ichiro Suzuki
Bill Terry
Frank Thomas
Jim Thome
Joe Tinker
Joe Torre
Alan Trammell
Pie Traynor
Arky Vaughan
Honus Wagner
Billy Wagner
Larry Walker
Lloyd Waner
Paul Waner
Earl Weaver
Zack Wheat
Hoyt Wilhelm
Billy Williams
Dick Williams
Ted Williams
Hack Wilson
Dave Winfield
Early Wynn
Carl Yastrzemski
Thomas Yawkey
Robin Yount

224 -Members 2/1/26

[discostu]

Nice work Steve.

[GUCD231]

Bump check for any new Members with Game Used.

[shanks25]

Thank you for this. I only need 5-6 more!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

Thank you for this. I only need 5-6 more!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

No problem. Happy hunting for the last few.

[shanks25]

One HOFer that I see missing is Mule Suttles. He has a bat card in 2019 National Treasures.

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

One HOFer that I see missing is Mule Suttles. He has a bat card in 2019 National Treasures.

Thank you so much! I was hoping something new would have popped up in a years time.

I will be on the lookout for one as well as revise the list to include him.

[shanks25]

Been working on my HOF GU collection a lot as of late and have made some purchases as well. After a full inventory, I think I'm 8 players short. Some are attainable, while other...not so much. Here's what I need.

Leon Day (glove) - Yeah, right!
Harry Hooper
Walter Johnson (ball) - Nope!
Addie Joss
Christy Mathewson (pants) - Doable but expensive
Joe Sewell
Billy Southworth


I also include some additional players in my "HOF" GU collection such as future locks like Jeter, Ichiro, Pujols, etc. I also include players like Rose, Maris, etc. Trying to get a Joe Jackson but no luck so far.

One small note that I'm sure everyone is aware of. I have a "Jimmy Collins" 2002 Topps GU bat card. Only problem is the photo (portrait) is actually Eddie Collins and it is assumed the GU bat is Eddie's as well...

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

Been working on my HOF GU collection a lot as of late and have made some purchases as well. After a full inventory, I think I'm 8 players short. Some are attainable, while other...not so much. Here's what I need.

Leon Day (glove) - Yeah, right!
Harry Hooper
Walter Johnson (ball) - Nope!
Addie Joss
Christy Mathewson (pants) - Doable but expensive
Joe Sewell
Billy Southworth


I also include some additional players in my "HOF" GU collection such as future locks like Jeter, Ichiro, Pujols, etc. I also include players like Rose, Maris, etc. Trying to get a Joe Jackson but no luck so far.

One small note that I'm sure everyone is aware of. I have a "Jimmy Collins" 2002 Topps GU bat card. Only problem is the photo (portrait) is actually Eddie Collins and it is assumed the GU bat is Eddie's as well...

Great effort! I'm counting 7 above. The last few are some of the hardest to come by for sure. Leon Day had (2) glove cards that sold this past august on Ebay. Both went for $560 each.

The Billy Southworth hat card is also a pretty tough card to find by himself. There's a triple player card of him which most collectors opt for.

As for the Walter Johnson ball it's the final card I need, but not willing to fork over $1000 for one anytime soon. It's so limited that I really can't consider it a must have since very few own one. It's also easy to say since I don't own one

There's a write up about the Collins mix-up some where on the web. I have one, but omitted it from the collection. The same can be said for all of the Topps Josh Gibson bat cards. Topps has only ever listed them as "Game Model" not "Used."

Here's my collection. Just waiting the Mule Suttles to arrive thanks to your tip off. https://www.blowoutforums.com/showthread.php?t=1248660

[shanks25]

Originally Posted by GUCD231

Great effort! I'm counting 7 above. The last few are some of the hardest to come by for sure. Leon Day had (2) glove cards that sold this past august on Ebay. Both went for $560 each.

The Billy Southworth hat card is also a pretty tough card to find by himself. There's a triple player card of him which most collectors opt for.

As for the Walter Johnson ball it's the final card I need, but not willing to fork over $1000 for one anytime soon. It's so limited that I really can't consider it a must have since very few own one. It's also easy to say since I don't own one

There's a write up about the Collins mix-up some where on the web. I have one, but omitted it from the collection. The same can be said for all of the Topps Josh Gibson bat cards. Topps has only ever listed them as "Game Model" not "Used."

Here's my collection. Just waiting the Mule Suttles to arrive thanks to your tip off. https://www.blowoutforums.com/showthread.php?t=1248660

I just took a look. Nice job and beautiful collection. I'd love to show mine but I still can't figure out how to post pics for the life of me!

It's amazing how you and I have the exact same card for so many HOFers. That's to be expected for a lot of the older guys with a very limited number of cards, but there a lot of the same with some of the newer and easy to find HOFers. I appreciate you sharing!!!

[whyconform]

Been following your obsession...was doing GU HOF and was 2-3 short in 2008 before I sold it ALL to focus on autos.....Great to see you're still at it and that they've added some tough names......

[shanks25]

Looking to add the four remaining cards that are somewhat "attainable"

Those include

Joss
Hooper
Southworth
Sewell

I've added the rest (not Jackson) lately or they're incoming...

[smapdi]

Man, two Leon Day gloves sold back in August and I missed them both. Wasn't going to go to $560+, but sad I didn't at least spot them.

[shanks25]

I saw that both went for $560. I suppose that’s the current market. A little steep for me right now.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

I just took a look. Nice job and beautiful collection. I'd love to show mine but I still can't figure out how to post pics for the life of me!

It's amazing how you and I have the exact same card for so many HOFers. That's to be expected for a lot of the older guys with a very limited number of cards, but there a lot of the same with some of the newer and easy to find HOFers. I appreciate you sharing!!!

Originally Posted by shanks25

Looking to add the four remaining cards that are somewhat "attainable"

Those include

Joss
Hooper
Southworth
Sewell

I've added the rest (not Jackson) lately or they're incoming...

I used Imgur to host them, it's free.

The last Southworth triple was a B/O at around $85. Hooper is $50- $60, but ended auctions show much less at $15-$20. Joss is about $50- $60 I paid $85 or so more for mine w/stripe. Sewell is about $15-$20.

I'll keep my eyes open if I see any reasonable.

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by whyconform

Been following your obsession...was doing GU HOF and was 2-3 short in 2008 before I sold it ALL to focus on autos.....Great to see you're still at it and that they've added some tough names......

Thanks for following. Autographs are fantastic, just way out of my league.

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by smapdi

Man, two Leon Day gloves sold back in August and I missed them both. Wasn't going to go to $560+, but sad I didn't at least spot them.

Originally Posted by shanks25

I saw that both went for $560. I suppose that’s the current market. A little steep for me right now.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The first Leon Day glove card was sold auction style that ended at $560. The second was someone looking to cash in their card and sold it as a BIN for the same price a week or so later. It's a tough card to find with only 100 copies. It's also highly sought after by those who collect Negro League players.

[shanks25]

Just won the Sewell for $6 a few minutes ago.

I agree with you. Hoopers have sold regularly for $15-$25. Five of the last six Joss jerseys went for $40-$50.

I’ve seen very few Southworth cards listed or completed. Might have to bite the bullet and spend more than anticipated.

As for now, I’m down to three attainable cards.

Thanks for the Imgur recommendation. I will look into it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

Just won the Sewell for $6 a few minutes ago.

I agree with you. Hoopers have sold regularly for $15-$25. Five of the last six Joss jerseys went for $40-$50.

I’ve seen very few Southworth cards listed or completed. Might have to bite the bullet and spend more than anticipated.

As for now, I’m down to three attainable cards.

Thanks for the Imgur recommendation. I will look into it!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nice!

I'll notify you if I see a Southworth anywhere.

[shanks25]

Aaaaaannnnnddd....just got a southworth. For a great price!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by shanks25

Aaaaaannnnnddd....just got a southworth. For a great price!!!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Nice! PM your way.

[rj.cataldo]

This is a great list! Anyone know if someone has done a similar exercise with Pro Football HOF?

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by rj.cataldo

This is a great list! Anyone know if someone has done a similar exercise with Pro Football HOF?

Thanks! Unfortunately I don't know if one exists.

Updated with the newest HOF addition of Marvin Miller.

[Moyni]

And you need to add Ted Simmons

[GUCD231]

Originally Posted by Moyni

And you need to add Ted Simmons

Hey Moyni,

I didn't realize he had one. Do you know the set and relic type?

Thanks!